All Forum Posts by: Sam McCormack
Sam McCormack has started 38 posts and replied 1290 times.
Post: New Real Estate Investor

- Real Estate Agent
- Cincinnati, OH
- Posts 1,324
- Votes 760
Quote from @Aaron Arguelles:
Hi everyone! My name is Aaron. I am a new real estate investor based out of Utah. My strategy and goal are to buy rental properties, specifically small 2-4 unit multifamily properties, and then scale up to larger commercial rental properties. I'm currently looking at the Mid West market and properties in Ohio, like the Cleveland and Akron area. I've been listening to some episodes from the Real Estate Rookie podcast and reading some books as well. I would love any advice or tips as I am going through this journey and working on finding my first property! Thanks everyone!
Welcome! Make sure you REALLY know who you're working with. It is worth flying out to see the market you invest in, meeting the people, especially agent and PM, you'll be working with. Build that trust relationship, make sure you're a CLIENT, not a customer, to your agent
Post: Hard to Pay My DSCR Mortgage

- Real Estate Agent
- Cincinnati, OH
- Posts 1,324
- Votes 760
Quote from @Lisa Holden:
Quote from @Sam McCormack:
Quote from @Lisa Holden:
In Ohio
I have a duplex - my only rental property. Both tenants were there when I purchased it in March, 2024. Both renewed their lease with me. The lower level tenant was due for lease end Feb 2026. He did a midnight move on July 3rd. I have painted, fixed up, new ceiling fans, window dressings, etc. and it is move in ready. Can’t find a tenant that qualifies: 3 times the rent in monthly income, pass credit check and criminal background check.
The upper unit is not generating enough to pay the mortgage, insurance, taxes and it is COSTING me $550 a month to own this property. Not good. I’ve listed it for sale with a realtor and considering not paying the mortgage anymore.
Thoughts? Anyone ever been in this predicament?
Thank you,
Lisa
What do you know about the area surrounding it? Are you investing Out of state with or without knowledge of the area?
I live 1/2 mile from the property. I am confident it is priced within market area pricing. I have a friend that lives within walking distance and pays the same for a 2 bedroom- mine is 3 bedroom 1700 square feet.
Just the cost of doing business then. You'll have vacancy and you'll be fine
Post: Hard to Pay My DSCR Mortgage

- Real Estate Agent
- Cincinnati, OH
- Posts 1,324
- Votes 760
Quote from @Lisa Holden:
In Ohio
I have a duplex - my only rental property. Both tenants were there when I purchased it in March, 2024. Both renewed their lease with me. The lower level tenant was due for lease end Feb 2026. He did a midnight move on July 3rd. I have painted, fixed up, new ceiling fans, window dressings, etc. and it is move in ready. Can’t find a tenant that qualifies: 3 times the rent in monthly income, pass credit check and criminal background check.
The upper unit is not generating enough to pay the mortgage, insurance, taxes and it is COSTING me $550 a month to own this property. Not good. I’ve listed it for sale with a realtor and considering not paying the mortgage anymore.
Thoughts? Anyone ever been in this predicament?
Thank you,
Lisa
What do you know about the area surrounding it? Are you investing Out of state with or without knowledge of the area?
Post: The Downfall of BiggerPockets Forums?

- Real Estate Agent
- Cincinnati, OH
- Posts 1,324
- Votes 760
Quote from @James Wise:
Quote from @Remington Lyman:
Quote from @Erik Estrada:
Quote from @Remington Lyman:
Hello BP Community!
Has anyone thought the content of the forums have been degrading recently? I feel like moderators and/or the staff of BP have been unable or unwilling to moderate the forums to the same standard they used to. It is riddled with self promotions and ChatGPT --- posts lately...
I feel the same way. It's been losing its essence for a few months now.
I think it is mostly AI's fault. If a Realtor wanted to promote their business they would have to work at it. You could not say you were a Realtor and had to not be spammy. Now you just put the rules into ChatGPT and have it design responses that comply with the rules while still promoting yourself. 0 thought behind the craft now.
We are all going to have to get yoked and dress up like Smerfs like @James Wise just to get any business now
People gotta use AI bro. They don't have an office filled with 400 19 year old real estate bro's hopped up on Prime telling everyone how cool Columbus is while they simultaneously hammer their chests and chant All Hail King Remmy
Hmmmmm, James you sound a little too familiar with this... something you gotta say?
Post: The Downfall of BiggerPockets Forums?

- Real Estate Agent
- Cincinnati, OH
- Posts 1,324
- Votes 760
Quote from @Remington Lyman:
Hello BP Community!
Has anyone thought the content of the forums have been degrading recently? I feel like moderators and/or the staff of BP have been unable or unwilling to moderate the forums to the same standard they used to. It is riddled with self promotions and ChatGPT --- posts lately...
I'm happy I stopped contributing to the spam. If someone asks about Cincinnati or wants to connect with someone from Cincinnati, then I leave a comment and shoot a message, but i'm no longer part of spam gang. Posting helpful things is a lot more fulfilling, a lot less degrading, and I don't feel like a cancer
Post: New Investor Seeking Multifamily Insights

- Real Estate Agent
- Cincinnati, OH
- Posts 1,324
- Votes 760
Quote from @Jordan Frisco:
Quote from @Sam McCormack:
Quote from @Andrew Lee:
I'm a new investor from California researching multifamily opportunities (2-4 units) in Columbus, Kansas City and Cincinnati. I've been analyzing properties and learning about the market, but I'd really value some local insights from experienced investors, agents or property managers.
Would love to learn:
- Which of these areas do you prefer for buy-and-hold rentals?
- Any neighborhoods I should add to my list?
- What's realistic for cash flow in today's market?
- Common mistakes to avoid as an out-of-state investor?
Appreciate any wisdom you can share.
One of the big mistakes I feel the people make, has to do with cash flow vs good areas. Yeah that 10% Coc ROI looks great, but it will quickly turn negative if you can't get a qualified tenant, a tenant gets evicted, or maybe there is a dead guy down the street. I wish I had stats but I can confidently say that a 5% Coc ROI in a lower crime/higher income area has better chances of being more profitable than that 10% Coc ROI in a higher crime/lower income area. Find that balance!
What are you using to model the crime rates and what makes you interested in your position to look for these lower income areas? Have you thought about biting the bullet and getting something in a higher income area?
Personal experience primarily. Stories from PMs. etc. but a more broad answer, common sense coming from experience
Post: Best Emerging Neighborhoods for Investing in Rental Units

- Real Estate Agent
- Cincinnati, OH
- Posts 1,324
- Votes 760
Quote from @Hilary Sackor:
Hey, I am currently struggling with searching for good areas in the city that would make for a great place to invest, with hopes that the area will continue to improve and become more renter-friendly. I was looking in the South and West Philly area, but don't want to limit my search, and could use some help here.
Quite a few markets in Ohio you can look in. I can only speak for Greater Cincinnati being a cheaper market that can still cash flow well. I don't know much about Philly besides that Eagle's fans suck! Kidding
Post: Out of state investing

- Real Estate Agent
- Cincinnati, OH
- Posts 1,324
- Votes 760
Quote from @Cody Miracle:
I have just recently discovered the possibility of real estate investing and I'm concerned whether I should invest out of state or not. I currently live in San Diego but seem to find the area too expensive for my liking. I am active duty military so I move around every few years for work, so I'm trying to decide if buying a property here and house hacking for the next couple of years until I move or making my first investment in a cheaper area is the better option.
Houseacking is the way to go in my opinion. And once you move out, you can fully rent it and do it somewhere else. OOS investing in still possible but I would recommend househacking. If you do deicide to go OOS in a cheaper market, Cincinnati is pretty good. Let me know if you have questions!
Post: Over saturation in OH Market?

- Real Estate Agent
- Cincinnati, OH
- Posts 1,324
- Votes 760
Quote from @Jordan Frisco:
Quote from @Christina Calderon:
Quote from @Jordan Frisco:
Craig,
Most affordable market to invest in based on doors and land in my opinion. Depends on where you are looking in Ohio. It is a Section 8 safe haven. East and west side of the state are hallowed out. Cincy and Cbus are growing, Cleveland is staying about the same YoY. Look near universities in Cincy and Cbus and near hospitals in Cleveland. Crime is rampant on the east side of Cleveland, the slums surrounding Columbus, and the west side of Cincinnati and the area between UC's campus and downtown Cincinnati. Columbus and Cincinnati definitely growing but not the same for the rest of Ohio.
Definitely agree with this. Cincinnati is the best Ohio market in my opinion, although a lot of people will argue for Cbus. It's affordable, you'll be able to find a good deal and make it work if you have the right team and time to look into the right neighborhoods.
I love Cincinnati! Beautiful place! Look also right across the river. Covington is a hot bed of people who want the lower taxes and still have the access to the city across the bridge!
nky is great
Post: Looking for Investor Friendling Agent in Cincinatti

- Real Estate Agent
- Cincinnati, OH
- Posts 1,324
- Votes 760
Quote from @Alex R.:
I'm a buy and hold real estate investor who currently splits my time between New Hampshire and Columbus, Ohio. I have property in both locations and am now looking to expand my portfolio into Cincinnati. Does anyone have recommendations on pseudo out of town investor friendly agents I should be working with to find and purchase property.
Thanks in advance for the help.
Hey Alex, i'm shooting you a message now