Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Rylan Lacey

Rylan Lacey has started 7 posts and replied 32 times.

Post: Multifamily refinancing in Phoenix

Rylan LaceyPosted
  • Developer
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Posts 33
  • Votes 27

Hello Biggerpockets!

I have a 24 unit apartment community that I am building ground up, and I’m about 4-6 months from finishing construction. All 3 bedroom 2 bath 1,000 sq ft with backyards, stainless steel appliances, washer and dryer in unit. Rents are around $2,000 a month when complete.

I’m looking to get ahead on an idea of financing for this. I usually build small apartment communities and then sell them to investors before they’re finished, but this one I’m planning on keeping.

I’m just looking for some brokers/lenders who would be interested in helping get the best refinancing options available. What are some rates people are getting? Are there 35-40 year amortized loans with 5 year balloons under 7%? Just looking for some good options.

Post: How to partner with Developers for new construction

Rylan LaceyPosted
  • Developer
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Posts 33
  • Votes 27
Quote from @Joel Matthews:
Quote from @Mike Smith:

I have people pitch this idea to me multiple times a year, so let me start with what not to do:

Landowner : I own a piece of property worth 100k, and I owe 95k on it.  Let's build a house on it and we can split the profits 50/50.

Me : So you put in 5k, I put in the 300k to build a home and 95k to payoff the lot, along with all my experience/knowledge and you feel 50/50 is a fair split?

Reality : Each party is paid a split on profits based on capital invested.  Each party is paid fairly for their work before profits are calculated.

Reality example :

Land cost : 100k

Build hard cost: 300k

Value at completion : 500k

Reasonable fee to build 300k home : 13% or 39k

Profit : 500k less 400k less 39k builder fee = 61k

Profit split (landowner paid in 5k): 5k/400k = 1.25% for landowner

395k/400k = 98.75% builder

Profit split (landowner paid 100k for lot, free and clear) = 100k/400k = 25%

Builder 300k/400k = 75%

For this reason, simply finding a piece of land without putting up significant capital or knowledge isn't worth much.


 Hi Mike,

thank you for taking the time to write out this thoughtful explanation. 

I had a few quick questions, hoping you can clarify. Why did you include the $95k note over to the builder expense column? Isn’t 100k note that the land owner owes enough for his stake in the deal regardless how much he put down to secure the purchase of the land?

Also confused with the below, at first it says the profit split is 1.25 and 98.75 and then the second line item says 75/25. How would you split the remaining $61k in your scenario? 75/25 split? 

Profit split (landowner paid in 5k): 5k/400k = 1.25% for landowner

395k/400k = 98.75% builder

Profit split (landowner paid 100k for lot, free and clear) = 100k/400k = 25%

Builder 300k/400k = 75%


thanks in advance,

Joel

I too get people all day long trying to get me to partner on projects and it’s just not simply worth it.

1. Why would I partner with someone when I can just put down the money on the land and do the project myself? I know land can be hard to come by sometimes but not hard enough for me to rely on a partner. If my capital is too tied up odds are I have enough work lined out for me for the next 12-24 months.

2. The margins are too low, especially on a deal this small. For splitting profits with a partner, I’d have to be doing a deal larger than ones I normally do to help mitigate the risk or cost.

Feels like with partnerships I’m educating my partner on a very niche market, and in doing so I’m cutting 50% of my profit compared to me just doing it without a partner.

I recommend doing it without a partner, hiring a good architect and find a decent builder to build it. Odds are there’s a hard money lender willing to do the deal out there, especially if you’re willing to put more money into the deal.

or if you really want to build this by partnering with a builder, If you owe $95k on a $100k land, when you get a construction loan, the land loan gets absorbed into the construction loan. If you’re both on the loan, you’re both on the hook for that land balance. So pay off the land free and clear with your own money, find a builder willing to partner 50/50 and have him build it for cost. You find the financing together (builder usually has some connections here) and split the money 50/50. His skin in the game is building it for cost and giving you the knowledge and experience to build it, your skin is your land owned free and clear.




Post: New construction 4 plex built and sold Phoenix

Rylan LaceyPosted
  • Developer
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Posts 33
  • Votes 27

Hi Steve,

yes I’m just finishing up the project and closing it out this week. I did 8 3 bed 2 baths and 10 2 bed 2 bath units (18 units total, 16,000 building sq ft). Construction costs increased over 30% when the supply chain issues hit because of Covid. Construction costs for a project this large costed me about $150 per sq ft for the buildings and another $17 per sq ft for the horizontal work and offsites, so $167 total cost per sq ft. This excludes financing costs. We originally had bids in place for $110 per sq ft before the supply chain issues.

value: $6,100,000
construction costs: $2,700,000
financing costs: $300,000
cost of land: 225,000
total profit: $2,875,000

I’ll upload some pictures soon on this project.


Quote from @Steve Walker:
Ryan - Did you end up doing the 18 unit deal? Would love to hear how that went. I live in the east valley and considering doing a small multifamily new build. Trying to learn more about the current state of construction costs. 


Quote from @Rylan Lacey:

Hi Biggerpockets,

Just wanted to share a project that I recently completed/sold and go over some numbers about the project.

Bought the lot in 2019 for $58,000 in south Phoenix (7th street and dobbins) and put 50% down and borrowed the rest from a private lender

Built the 4 plex for $400k ($100k per unit)

Asked $750k on the sales price, got $800k with multiple offers in the first week

Each unit is 2 bed 1 bath, 750 sq ft and rents between $1,350-$1,450. Sold around a 6% cap rate so the buyer got a great deal on a new build with warranties and I made a profit I was happy with

I have an 18 unit project going in south Phoenix as well and will update on that project in the coming months.


Post: Multi-family development..LOST in the Sauce!🥴

Rylan LaceyPosted
  • Developer
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Posts 33
  • Votes 27
Originally posted by @Harish Nandipati:

Hi Johnny,

I am a developer . I am currently working on a development in Tucson and SFH from ground up in Mesa. I am also working on putting things together for a 20 to 30 unit project in east valley or East Phoenix . It's a hectic process but I think at the end it will be fruitful and definitely better than rehabbing 1960s construction. The value you add is good for several decades . I am willing to share my pains. Let's connect some time this week . I will leave you my number .

Paul summed it up really well above. Parking, turnaround for fire and turnaround for trash are the biggest project killers in Arizona. Honestly if you can get a builder to answer the phone they’re going to be around $150-$175 per sq ft to build (vertical and horizontal) and 6 months out.


Also Financing these are not a walk in the park, especially if you’re new to the game. Expect to put in an additional $30k-40k per unit you build in order to make up the equity required for banks to loan you the money (unless you can cross collateralize other free and clear properties). Then add on payment reserves, points and fees.

You really gotta know your stuff on these things  before you start. That’s why everyone’s in the rehab game and not the new construction game. Takes a lot of risk and cash to make it happen. But once you get in and get some experience, it’s totally worth it.

Post: New construction 4 plex built and sold Phoenix

Rylan LaceyPosted
  • Developer
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Posts 33
  • Votes 27
Originally posted by @Preetham Gowda:

Congratulations Ryan. The numbers and the property look great. Couple of quick questions  How did you fund the project? HM/self-funding/bank etc? Your overall construction costs came to about $135 per sqft? 

 I got the project funded with a hard money lender here in Arizona. My actual construction loan was $305,000 for the project plus $30,000 owed on the land, and then the lender allowed me to cash out refinance once the project was nearly complete with a total loan amount of $400,000. So cost per sq ft for underground/utilities, offsites, and buildings came to $102 per sq ft. Im able to get it cheap since im also a licensed GC. Due to increased costs due to covid however I’m right around $125 per sq ft for construction now on my other projects

Post: New construction 4 plex built and sold Phoenix

Rylan LaceyPosted
  • Developer
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Posts 33
  • Votes 27
Originally posted by @Brett Tvenge:

@Rylan Lacey nice work rylan, your numbers and work look great

Thanks Brett,

With the rapid appreciation here in Phoenix I’m hoping the numbers will be even better with the next couple of projects
 

Post: New construction 4plex Phoenix

Rylan LaceyPosted
  • Developer
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Posts 33
  • Votes 27

Investment Info:

Small multi-family (2-4 units) other investment in Phoenix.

Purchase price: $58,000
Cash invested: $30,000
Sale price: $800,000

New construction 4 plex, 2 bed 1 bath with private backyards for bottom units. Rents between $1,350-1,450 per unit. Built for $400k including land and sold for $800k

How did you finance this deal?

Private money lender

Post: New construction 4 plex built and sold Phoenix

Rylan LaceyPosted
  • Developer
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Posts 33
  • Votes 27

Hi Biggerpockets,

Just wanted to share a project that I recently completed/sold and go over some numbers about the project.

Bought the lot in 2019 for $58,000 in south Phoenix (7th street and dobbins) and put 50% down and borrowed the rest from a private lender

Built the 4 plex for $400k ($100k per unit)

Asked $750k on the sales price, got $800k with multiple offers in the first week

Each unit is 2 bed 1 bath, 750 sq ft and rents between $1,350-$1,450. Sold around a 6% cap rate so the buyer got a great deal on a new build with warranties and I made a profit I was happy with

I have an 18 unit project going in south Phoenix as well and will update on that project in the coming months.

Post: New construction 4 plex built and sold Phoenix

Rylan LaceyPosted
  • Developer
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Posts 33
  • Votes 27

Hi Biggerpockets,

Just wanted to share a project that I recently completed/sold and go over some numbers about the project.

Bought the lot in 2019 for $58,000 in south Phoenix (7th street and dobbins) and put 50% down and borrowed the rest from a private lender

Built the 4 plex for $400k ($100k per unit) 

Asked $750k on the sales price, got $800k with multiple offers in the first week

Each unit is 2 bed 1 bath, 750 sq ft and rents between $1,350-$1,450. Sold around a 6% cap rate so the buyer got a great deal on a new build with warranties and I made a profit I was happy with

I have an 18 unit project going in south Phoenix as well and will update on that project in the coming months.

Post: Phoenix AZ Multifamily development feedback

Rylan LaceyPosted
  • Developer
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Posts 33
  • Votes 27

I personally like to break it down per unit for non vertical construction. I’m usually plugged in at about $30k per unit for all horizontal work and about $110 per sq ft. However I’m GC and developer so my costs should be lower. I think $135 per sq ft is reasonable for vertical construction but I’d plug in at least $50k per unit for horizontals. Underground companies are outrageously high