Thanks to everyone for the input so far. @Michael Totman You're 100% correct; I meant that, on most projects, you only recoup 60-70% of the cost (based on the data I've seen). ROI was definitely not the correct term in this case, so thank you for clarifying.
Here's a little more info on the property. I just purchased it about 3 months ago. It's in a small, but quickly growing area. My loan on the house was for $189,000. The property appraised for $200,000. It's about 2100 sq. feet with 3 bedrooms and two bathrooms. It's about 10 years old, nothing fancy but most things are in good condition.
The house has a basement that's nearly half finished. The living area of the basement has lights, dry wall, paint, electric outlets, etc. It's just missing flooring. My hope would be that, simply by adding carpet to that area would allow me to consider it a half finished basement and would bump up the property value.
Some of the other projects/improvements I've considered:
- The back yard has no lawn. I'd like to plant grass back there and turn it into a real yard. Maybe even add a small deck (DIY).
- I have connections that may allow me to purchase some flooring at whole sale price and have considered upgrading the flooring through the entry, the living area, and the kitchen.
- The kitchen is in good condition, but slightly outdated. I'd like to repaint the kitchen cabinets, add hardware to them, and add a nicer faucet.
- I could also add a bathroom to the basement fairly easily, but I'm not sure how useful this would be as there are currently no bedrooms down there.
I'd love to hear anyone's opinions or ideas on the strategy that may be most beneficial.