Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Ryan Marble

Ryan Marble has started 5 posts and replied 16 times.

I live in a small town in eastern Arizona, about 7000 people, and we have a pretty serious shortage of rental properties. Finding multi unit properties for sale is almost unheard of. Just wondering, if buying a lot and building a duplex, triplex, or quad plex is a good option in today's market? I would not be living in any of the units as I already have primary residence in town. Any thoughts or questions? I'm still quite new to real estate investing and i'm looking for ways to get started in my own town.

Quote from @Pete Slaga:
Quote from @Ryan Marble:

I'm just starting in the STR market in the Orlando and Tampa areas and was wondering what all of you experienced vacation rental investors would say are the 3 most important tips or advice to running a successful/profitable vacation rental in these areas? Thanks in advance!


Sign up for a trial of Airdna and do some research.   
#1 Location As others have stated Orlando and Tampa (Tampa City or Tampa area like Clearwater?)  are totally different markets.     
Prime location is the most important thing.   Orlando you want to be near the theme parks.   Tampa you better be on the water.

#2 Find a niche.     I would argue that you are better off having a smaller place in Orlando that fits a family under 6 people.  There are way too many 5+ bedrooms themed homes. (oversupply).    In Tampa or Tampa area the opposite is true as big homes do not have a large market share

#3. Does it pencil out?   Can you make money.  I would say your best bet is to see if you can purchase a home with an assumable mortgage.


 Pete, 

I am on AirDNA and run the numbers constantly. How much can I trust those numbers? I have heard they can lag behind? I also compare with Rabbu numbers and use their STR calculator to run numbers. Do you use any other data sights that might help determining accurate numbers? Also, how hard is the process of assuming a mortgage?

Quote from @JD Martin:
Quote from @Ryan Marble:
Quote from @JD Martin:

My top 3 tips for the Orlando area:

1. Pick another area;

2. Pick another area;

3. Pick another area.

The "everybody" niche - 2-5 bedroom, 2-3 bath - has so many people you can still find places going for under $100/night with a pool. It's just insane. The only hope of making any money here is either be on the tiny end that you can turn into a showcase for not that much money, or the high end 6-10 bedroom homes that can hold 2 families or 1 really big family. There's not as much competition on either side. I have a 4/3 3k square feet and it is a constant battle with bottom feeders for bookings, and I have a great place and all 5-star reviews. But lots of people are just looking for a place to crash and don't care about that, at least until they get there and find out the place is a dump. 

JD, where would you suggest I look? I'm looking for somewhere that at the very least, would make a great winter home when I retire in fifteen to twenty years....

 You're going to have to pick your poison. Figure out where *you* want to live when you retire, then work backwards from there. I picked where I am because it's 10 minutes from my father, who is about to be 80. I had hoped that the natural draw of Disney etc would work in my favor but there's just too much inventory. If you pick a different area, you may have less demand. Or the housing costs may just be too high to cover your expenses. You can still get decent buys for the price in my area but you can't make the expenses unless you are in a very small niche and drop a lot of money on themes and the like.

What I tell people is that if it won't work as a long term rentals don't do it at all. You need to at least have several exit plans.

What other areas in Florida would you recommend for a winter/retirement home as well as for STR's in the mean time or during the summer? I am heavily looking into the Tampa area as well as the Cocoa Beach area. But I'm not dead set on anything accept that I would like to be in Florida.
Quote from @JD Martin:

My top 3 tips for the Orlando area:

1. Pick another area;

2. Pick another area;

3. Pick another area.

The "everybody" niche - 2-5 bedroom, 2-3 bath - has so many people you can still find places going for under $100/night with a pool. It's just insane. The only hope of making any money here is either be on the tiny end that you can turn into a showcase for not that much money, or the high end 6-10 bedroom homes that can hold 2 families or 1 really big family. There's not as much competition on either side. I have a 4/3 3k square feet and it is a constant battle with bottom feeders for bookings, and I have a great place and all 5-star reviews. But lots of people are just looking for a place to crash and don't care about that, at least until they get there and find out the place is a dump. 

JD, where would you suggest I look? I'm looking for somewhere that at the very least, would make a great winter home when I retire in fifteen to twenty years....
Quote from @Alice Horn:
Quote from @Ryan Marble:

I'm just starting in the STR market in the Orlando and Tampa areas and was wondering what all of you experienced vacation rental investors would say are the 3 most important tips or advice to running a successful/profitable vacation rental in these areas? Thanks in advance!

Good morning @Ryan Marble!

Orlando and Tampa are very different markets, so here are my top 3 tips for Orlando. As property managers, we see up close on a daily basis which properties perform best and are the most popular with guests…as well as the ongoing challenges.

1. AS with any RE investment identify the top locations. Our tourists prefer gated communities with great amenities, not too far from Disney - Windsor Island, Solara, Windsor at Westside to name a few. Also remember to consider the positioning within the resort - does it have a lake or forest view? Near the clubhouse? Etc.

2. Great theming. Check Airbnb listings to see what’s booking - you’ll notice lavish game rooms, bunk beds with slides, murals, etc. Make sure the home has quality furniture and items that don’t fall apart in a few years. We can help you find the right decorator if needed.

3. 6-8 Bedroom house with pool and spa. Others may tell you to go larger, but we find the most consistent bookings for this size. A pool is a must, pools with spas book better.

Many will tell you Orlando is saturated, which it is. It is also the top tourist destination in the US, and it is a year-round market with fairly consistent performance year after year. If you have the right type of home, it will book well.


 You say 6-8 bedroom house with a pool and spa? I wanted to start small with 3-4 bedroom condo? Is that a bad idea?

I'm just starting in the STR market in the Orlando and Tampa areas and was wondering what all of you experienced vacation rental investors would say are the 3 most important tips or advice to running a successful/profitable vacation rental in these areas? Thanks in advance!

Post: Cash on cash return

Ryan MarblePosted
  • Investor
  • Arizona
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Sarah Kensinger:
Quote from @Ryan Marble:
Quote from @Sarah Kensinger:

Must be 20-25% for us to purchase the STR. Other investors just want the tax benefits, so it depends on your goals.

The most accurate site for data is Airdna, which pulls numbers from Airbnb and VRBO. Airdna has purchased full licensing rights, so they have years' worth of data. Free sites like Rabbu, Awning, etc., only have the last couple months' worth of data. Then they extrapolate or lean heavy into the algorithm to come up with next 10 months' worth of data. So, on those sites you do need to be careful, and I found the numbers to be all over the place. 


What recommend to be the best Airdna subscription option for someone like me that is just starting out in STR's?

What all do you want to use it for? I almost think basic would be a good fit for someone new with one listing.


The basic should have everything I would need as a new STR investor with one vacation rental? I would imagine I can always upgrade if needed, right?

Post: Cash on cash return

Ryan MarblePosted
  • Investor
  • Arizona
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Sarah Kensinger:

Must be 20-25% for us to purchase the STR. Other investors just want the tax benefits, so it depends on your goals.

The most accurate site for data is Airdna, which pulls numbers from Airbnb and VRBO. Airdna has purchased full licensing rights, so they have years' worth of data. Free sites like Rabbu, Awning, etc., only have the last couple months' worth of data. Then they extrapolate or lean heavy into the algorithm to come up with next 10 months' worth of data. So, on those sites you do need to be careful, and I found the numbers to be all over the place. 


What recommend to be the best Airdna subscription option for someone like me that is just starting out in STR's?

Post: Cash on cash return

Ryan MarblePosted
  • Investor
  • Arizona
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Account Closed:
Quote from @Ryan Marble:

What is considered a good cash on cash return? Also, what is everyone's opinion of rabbu.com and the accuracy of their property analysis and projections? Does anyone have any other websites or processes that they use to analyze a property for STR investment purposes?


 It needs to be higher then the US treasury for it to make sense. you would be surprised how few people, particularly brokers, can comprehend that 


 Current US Treasury is at 5.085%.... does that sound right? So, at the very least, it needs to be above that to be profitable?

Post: HELOC to buy STR's?

Ryan MarblePosted
  • Investor
  • Arizona
  • Posts 16
  • Votes 7

Is it a bad idea to use a HELOC to pay the down payment for my first short term rental investment? And how do I factor that in the Cash on Cash return when analyzing properties? I'm still trying to learn all I can as I look for an opportunity to get my foot in the door to investing in vacation rentals.