@Justin Lentz I work with investors all over the world who are investing in the Indianapolis area. Most of my clients are from California (because finding real estate investment opportunities can be tough) but I have worked with clients from Israel to Singapore.
There are lots of great midwest and southern markets that people have found success in... for years Indy, Memphis, and Kansas City were very common and we are seeing other options like Oklahoma City and some Pennsylvania markets as well.
I live in Indy, so I'm a little biased, but... other than the obvious numbers, there are some other metrics to take in to consideration. There are a variety of other reasons that different markets work well for investors.
How is the regulatory environment?Indianapolis tends to be a business/contract oriented state. This means evictions and other complications tend to rule in favor of the investor if you do all the right things.
Understand property taxes in your target market. I've seen things that look deals get shredded to very thin margins by changes in property taxes.
What kind of experts and professionals are available to build your team with? I had a friend who purchased a 40 unit building in a smaller market and was very unsatisfied with her property manager, but struggled to find a replacement. It was a big frustration to her for over a year. When investing out of state or area, ensure that you have options if you have to replace members of your team.
Visit your target markets. While this isn't necessary, the most successful investors that I usually deal with know their target markets pretty well and usually visit them at least every year. Indianapolis can be very "block by block" and it's something that really needs to be experienced to understand it. It's also nice to meet local investors, professionals, and other players to bounce ideas off of and get a general idea of what is and is not working for people in those markets.