@Sarah Gabriel, @Tim Orenbuch, @Slawek Jakubowski, @Kevin Paulk, @Francis Nguyen, & @Jeremy Fisher,
Thank you all again for the wise advise and words of encouragement on my first rental property. I wanted to give an update on how I made out with this deal. To start, I did end up going through with the purchase. I spent about a month rehabbing the property (see comment above), and spent just over $6k. My total cost for the project was $86k, all-in. As mentioned in my initial post, the purchased & rehab were financed using the HELOC on my primary residence. I then was still able to refinance my primary residence as planned, which combined the two houses (the rental & my primary) into one loan. I also pulled additional cash out on that same loan to finance a 1-bedroom apartment addition on my current primary residence (which I obtained a zoning variance for earlier this year). I am working on the construction documents for that addition now, but that's another post....
So at this point in my journey, my fears are gone because I now know that I can afford the monthly payments even if it sits vacant. It obviously wouldn't be ideal, but knowing I probably won't lose my hat takes a huge weight off of my shoulders.
I was planning to rent it for around $950/month, but listening to the advice of one of my clients who invests in that neighborhood, I decided to list it for $1,195. Because, why not? If I don't get a bite in a week, I'll lower it. Surprisingly the listing did really well. It actually hovered in the top 10 viewed listings for almost a month. I took photos with a wide angle lens that I borrowed from work. I also paid an online company $32 to virtually stage the living room, and I really think that tiny investment brought a lot of people to my listing. It's something that I always see on higher end listings, but never in C-class. I think it gave me an edge over some of the other listings.
Anyway, after being listed for about a month, I am happy to report that I signed a lease with a nice couple yesterday. It rented for the $1,195 (+ $55 pet fee).
After stashing maintenance, Cap-Ex & vacancy reserves, It will cash-flow $313/month. ($0 out of pocket).
So, I just want to thank you guys for being the positive voices that I needed when I suffering from fear.....
Warmest Regards,
Rob