Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: John Cashin

John Cashin has started 8 posts and replied 33 times.

Post: New to Indiana, Self Introduction

John CashinPosted
  • Greenwood, IN
  • Posts 35
  • Votes 2

Hi, I'm moving to the Indy area this month and will be getting back into the real estate game after a long hiatus thanks life happening for a while (relocations, wife, kids, corporate ladder, etc.).  Now that I've reached stability and have no plans to move again thanks to Indy being a great city, I'm itching to get back into RE investing.  My experience is a single completed house flip, not extensive by any means but some proof of my willingness to take action in this business and ability to secure funding and close on a deal.

I'll be joining in the local REIA activities and possibly meeting some of you! My initial goals are simply to learn the market, network, and start building a team. I plan to wholesale with integrity by sourcing my own deals, build a local rental portfolio, and possibly do some house flipping again.

Here are some things I'm working on the short term:

  • Networking with agents in my area (Johnson county)
  • Finding local cash buyers
  • Finding recommendations for title companies, property management, etc.
  • Indiana real estate laws & other info particular to Indy

Again, I'm looking forward to meeting some of you.  Thanks for reading!

Post: Selling my personal home ...or not?

John CashinPosted
  • Greenwood, IN
  • Posts 35
  • Votes 2

Thanks for the input everyone, much appreciated!

Post: Selling my personal home ...or not?

John CashinPosted
  • Greenwood, IN
  • Posts 35
  • Votes 2

good questions, I would use a property manager in both scenarios.  I also already have contacts for repairs having lived here for 7 years.  I wouldn't personally fix things in either situation.

I am planning on buying rentals in Indy as well, so there could be some synergies in having properties in close proximity.  But I'm not against the idea of having out of state properties.

Post: Selling my personal home ...or not?

John CashinPosted
  • Greenwood, IN
  • Posts 35
  • Votes 2

I'm relocating from Ohio to Indiana and was selling my house through traditional channels.  However, today I started wondering about other options.  I'm already in the process of buying my new home but I've been starting to consider if renting my current home makes more sense than selling it.  We've had some interest but no offers yet (one buyer is "making a decision" tomorrow) and if it doesn't sell, I'm not sure I care.  

The home value is in the $300-$330k range and from what I can find so far, rent would go for $2000-$2800 but I'm struggling to find comps.  How do you find rental comps?  What are the recommended tools besides craigslist / trulia?  Also, the RNC this July is also throwing things off with people trying to rent their homes out for $10k+ for the month (!!!).  That's not really an option for us anyway since we'll be moving just after that.

My property doesn't meet the typical 1% rule, but I'm not sure it's a bad decision.  Mortgage & insurance is about $1800/mo but that's on a 20yr mortgage and I'd likely re-fi into a 30 to get my equity out (decent amount).  Maintenance in the next few years should be low considering I just fixed everything in order to sell, and appliances have all been upgraded in the last couple of years.  The house is about 17 years old so a new roof should still be a ways off.  How should I estimate maintenance in this situation?

Has anyone else done something like this?  Thoughts?  Things to consider?

Oof, just looked at the pictures.  What are you estimating for the rehab cost?

I may have missed this in the 6 pages of posts, but where did you originally find the deal?  Was it through a contact or some other method?  Also, what attracted you to look in Dayton being from Vegas?

Post: Re-introduction from a really old member

John CashinPosted
  • Greenwood, IN
  • Posts 35
  • Votes 2

Hi again, this forum has changed a lot in 10 years.  I was a member back when the forum was the old style message board format.  I joined in 2005 when I was 23 and was looking to flip my first home.  I did end up flipping a single family home, failing majestically in the process.  I bought a probate in Long Island for $385k with zero down that needed way more work than I should have taken on with my partner, as a first flip.  

Everything in the home was changed.  We replaced the roof, and then 25 sheets of plywood under it that had rotted out.  We took out wood paneling on the walls that had 3 layers of smoke infused wall paper beneath it (really should have just ripped out the drywall...).  The electrical system had to be upgraded.  The kitchen was gutted, flooring redone (refinished hardwood and tiling work in the kitchen.  Ripped out an old aluminum awning & enclosure on the back patio.  Put in a brick walkway.  Filled a 40 yard dumpster.  Replaced 23 windows.  The list goes on and on, it was a full reno. 

I had a chance to sell it at $450k FSBO and I blew it, I read some terrible negotiation advice and instead of following my gut, I listened to the bad advice. Had I sold it at $450k, we probably would have made around $5k/ea but instead we ended up having to sit on it for about a year, and sold it later for $410k, to the same buyer.  On top of that, we had to pay the neighbor $10k due to some property line issues and laws in NY.  So we lost $40 or 50k, plus the difference in rent vs. the mortgage.  We had a zero down full interest mortgage and taxes on the property were $13k/year.  All in all, I probably lost around $40k myself.

Believe it or not, I do not regret the experience in the slightest.  In the grand scheme of things, it was a drop in the bucket.  I learned an incredible amount in that short time and it made me a stronger person.  I've since been very successful climbing the corporate ladder and I've had some incredible years, especially over the last 5.  The only reason I didn't continue in real estate at the time was because I moved across state lines multiple times the last 10 years (about to move to Indy) and I focused on my current career path rather than learning new markets over and over.  Now that I've essentially achieved my goals, I'm ready to get back into the real estate game as I sell my current home and pull out my equity which would give me plenty to throw down a few down payments.  I've also made some great connections with some possible investors over the years through work and friends.

The next few months I plan to re-educate myself. My goal in life is to be financially independent and give back to the community in areas where I've benefit from. I've listened to the last 10 podcasts (and continue to work my way back), attended my first BP webinar, started picking up some good books recommended from the podcasts, and am working on making new connections in the Indy area. After I decide on a target area and can clearly articulate the strategy I would like to go with (leaning towards multifamily rentals at the moment, possibly BRRRR method to start), I'll start making offers. I'm looking forward to being back in the game! If you're from the Indy area, feel free to say hi!

Found the old pictures if anyone is interested (pre-renos, also pre-imgur...): https://share.shutterfly.com/share/received/welcom...

Only after picture I could find:

Post: Foreclosures - What happens to the owner?

John CashinPosted
  • Greenwood, IN
  • Posts 35
  • Votes 2

interesting... thanks for that info.

Post: Foreclosures - What happens to the owner?

John CashinPosted
  • Greenwood, IN
  • Posts 35
  • Votes 2

Hi, i'm just curious as to what happens to the owner of the foreclosed home. I'm assuming, for one, that his/her credit goes down the tubes. But what else happens? Are they "free and clear" of the property, or does any money they make after the foreclosure still owed to the bank? If their credit does in fact go down the drain when foreclosing, are they likely to lose all of their current credit cards as well?

i'm just trying to better understand the position of people who may at sometime foreclose - and i think this information would help.

Post: Finding the best seller, post rehab

John CashinPosted
  • Greenwood, IN
  • Posts 35
  • Votes 2

Hey all, long time no post here. I finished a flip in october, and i thought i had it sold right off the bat - to a cash buyer. unfortunately, the deal fell through and now its winter (granted, an unseasonably warm one). Anyway, I think that my real estate agent isn't doing all that she can to sell my house - she has an open house once or twice a month, and has it listed in MLS... obviously the house isn't selling so I'm back here for more real estate advice!

How do I find a TOP selling real estate agent, specifically in the NY, Long Island area (suffolk county). looking online doesn't yield too much. I'm also open to a bird dog that might be able to move the deal, or any other method of selling.

also, any other advice on selling a flipped property would also be appreciated. Thanks!