@Jonathan Greene At risk of getting sucked in here, I did go ahead and click on @Scott Meech's post here: https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/925/topics/1217313-dete...
I often agree with what you have to say, but in this case, I have to disagree.
I feel that the BP forums are literally for the kind of question Scott asked. Scott is new to MTR, and did the homework of setting up his profile, and even buying a pro membership, and researching a property to ask for opinions about in response.
Think about how many people come on and post about how they have $300K+ and no plan! I worry that these posts risk them being targeted by bad actors in the space.
Scott is nowhere close to "bad" in the context of what a lot of newer members post to the community.
I can't think of a better use for the forums than in allowing members like Scott to test ideas like that MTR and get feedback from the community. I am sure that Scott is aware that he should do lots of research before buying an MTR, but if a part of that research can't be posting a potential deal to the forums and getting community input/guidance on how to think about it, what is the BP forum even for?
Your responses are usually great, but in this case it came across to me like you were telling him to do more homework and to come back later when he had a better question.
We don't want Scott to go away! We want him to come back, and to engage with the community, learn how to ask the right questions, buy investment property that makes him rich, and for him to have such an awesome experience and make so much money in real estate over the next few years that he stays on BiggerPockets for 10-20 more years answering questions for other newbies, learning from the example of @miguel del mazo - who provided an incredible and useful response.
We want more people like Scott to post to the forum.
I think that there's a spin to your post that needs to incorporate the idea of being "welcoming" and "encouraging" of every member to pursue the long-term benefits of real estate responsibly, even as we of course do not want to encourage irresponsible real estate investing decisions.
Curious to hear other's thoughts here.