Hi Nicholas --- i've been vetting and trying to decide between 3 potential PMs so far, and mixed experiences to date. For context, we're just closing now and will make a decision and start showing next week.
With Chris at Integrity (based out of poughkeepsie) i found that he hasn't been willing to accept constructive criticism--- which normally wouldn't matter, but it's around his agreements, which are entirely unenforceable in court, and since i started trying to give him redlines, he's totally ghosted.
Jim (out of newburgh) is highly professional, but has been a bit cold (and seems expensive) but is our current top choice
Last is a woman named Tecia Poulas, who was the sellers agent and is really well connected and informed, but has never been a PM before, and so we're expecting a bit more effort required than going with someone turnkey like Jim or Chris.
Anyway, i'll keep this thread updated, and please let me know if you find anyone else!