You're negative when only taking into account mortgage loan, taxes and insurance? For your first property? I would not be as fast to say it makes sense as the others...
Maintenance, capex, and vacancy are going to be a bigger issue than the $200 a month you already know you'll be out. Do you account for property management expenses, or do you plan to self manage? If you plan to use property managers, keep in mind the extra costs on top of the flat %, like mark-ups on repairs, leasing fees etc. If you plan to self manage, being new increases the chances of you making mistakes while screening tenants, filing for evictions etc. This property could quickly become a nightmare.
I am not saying you shouldn't do it, just make sure you know what you're getting into. Some markets just don't make sense for rentals, especially with the current environment of high rates and high prices. Appreciation is great, but those of us who lived through 2008-2010 know it's by no means guaranteed.