I read this thread recently and was very interested in the topic and responses. It seems to me that there may be some misunderstandings about this topic. I will do my best to address the issues that have been brought by everybody.
The 1st thing that a life insurance policy is for, is just that, a life policy for the benefit of the survivors needs. That said, some life policies have additional features that lead a person to think of them as an investment. They are NOT an investment, however they have some features like investments, but they are not investments.
2nd is the argument of term vs. whole life. Here is the best way to determine what you really need; If you need a life policy for a specified period of time, but it may not be around when you pass, then term is most likely your best bet, but not always. For instance, most terms are bought as 10, 20, 30 year policies. Another little known fact is that term is typically not allowed past the age of 80, so if you want it when you die, and your family has a longevity history well beyond 80, a term may not be the best choice. If you can tell me exactly the day you will die, I can get you exactly the correct policy, if you cant, then you need to hedge your bets and make sure its there when you need it. Thats where some form of whole life comes in.
If you want to be assured that the policy will be there when you die, the only way to do that is with some form of whole life policy, and make sure the premiums are paid or its in a paid up status, so it is active when you pass. That said, lets talk about some of the features of a whole life and why or why not, it may be a useful to for you in life and real estate?
Whole life has 3 major components from a buyers standpoint, 1) life insurance policy 2) cash value 3) dividends
If you decide to borrow from the cash value, 1st you dont have to qualify like other loans, you just request the money against what value you have in there without lapsing the policy. If you only do policy loans, you will not be taxed. The only time you will ever be taxed on your gains is if you surrender or lapse the policy, but policy loans are not a taxable event. You can decide if you want to pay the loan back, when you want to pay it back, and at what amounts you want to pay it back. Lots of nice features there.
My company currently pays a guarnteed rate of 3% on your cash value, in addition you typically get dividends. Now dividends are not guarnteed, but in the 75 years of offering life policies, we have never NOT paid a dividend. Currently our dividend rate is between 2-2.5%. That means that your internal rate of return is 5-5.5% and can be taken out non taxed, that would be equivilant to a 5.88 - 9% in the market. However at least 3% of our is guarnteed, nothing in the market is guarnteed.
The other major feature about a whole life policy is that you can choose from many dividend options. The one I like and set most of my clients up with is the dividends buy additional paid up life insurance. This will then grow your death benefit over the years as well, so if you do take out policy loans, it then will be against a higher death benefit and cash value.
I own a large amount of whole life on my whole family. My wife and I are going to use the cash value to help supplement our retirement and yet there will always be a certain amount of death benefit left for our heirs.
Now am I saying that a whole life policy is the best tool for real estate investing, no I'm not, I'm sure there are many other tools that can be used, but I am saying, that you 1st truly need to understand it, and yes, I feel it can be one of a few great tools in your tool belt to accomplish many of lifes goals, including investing in real estate.