Raj,
It's indeed concerning to hear about the issues you're facing with tenant verification. Here are a few steps you can take to improve the reliability of your tenant screening process:
1. Don't rely on a single tenant verification service. Cross-reference information from multiple reputable sources to ensure accuracy.
2. Meeting potential tenants in person can give you a better sense of their character and reliability. Ask questions about their rental history, employment, and reasons for moving.
3. Instead of just accepting pay stubs or income statements, contact the employer directly to verify employment status and income.
4. Call previous landlords to get a sense of the applicant’s rental history. Ask about their behavior as tenants, payment history, and any issues that arose during their tenancy.
5. In addition to nationwide checks, conduct local criminal background checks for more detailed information. Some local offenses might not appear on nationwide databases.
6. Consider hiring a professional tenant screening service that offers more in-depth checks, including eviction history, credit reports, and criminal background checks.
7. Look for inconsistencies in the information provided on the application and during the interview process. Any discrepancies could be a red flag.
8. Ensure all your screening practices comply with Fair Housing Laws and other legal guidelines to avoid potential legal issues.
Improving your tenant verification process can help you find more reliable tenants and protect your investment. If you continue to face issues, consulting with a property management company or legal advisor might also be beneficial.
Best of luck with your rental properties!
Seth