Hi, I've met several investors who always have a home warrenty on their properties as a part of their business model. Even on fresh BRRRRs. They swear by this approach. I have mixed feelings. I bought policies on a few properties and decided after 1-2 years that doing so was a waste. 5 years later one needed new washer, dryer, and furnance that may have been covered had I kept the policy.
I have bought rehabs from other investors and wished I had something to cover issues discovered later. I bought another property where the water hearter was old. I thought I'd have a few years to save reserves. It died after about 18 months. That was a painful $1600 out of pocket.
I have one success so far. I bought a property from another investor who had a policy that transferred. I kept the policy going because I knew the HVAC system was on its last legs. Seller refused to budge on price. Now, 2 years later, I am replacing the system. The insurace was willing to pay for repairs but with their contribution & mine combined, I was close to the cost of a new one. So, almost $2600 of my new system will be covered and I get to pick my own contractor. Because I've only owned the property for 2 years, this cost would definately have exceeded its reserves.
Future plan? I'm thinking if I rehab the property and replace the big ticket items, I'll skip the insurance. If I buy a property where the home inspection reveals aged items and I cannot negotiate the price down, I may opt for the insurance for a couple years until the property has some reserves. If a property I've owned a long time has certain items getting up in age and I know something big is gonna go, I will consider starting a policy. Still working through this one...