@Dan H. To clarify, when I say condo's I'm speaking of large complexes with 1/1 units. The other 2-4 MF units in the area range from 2/1 - 3/2 configurations. It seems that the duplex I'm referencing is the only one of its kind (at least from what's posted online). I haven't seen any 1/1 duplexes in any listing in San Diego to compare it to. There are many 1/1 "cottages" that people have added onto their homes. Which in certain areas is very common. The locations of the properties isn't anything to write home about though.
I do understand the need to create a larger funnel that will eventually lead to a tenant; and I've discussed this with my agent who has been helping me navigate the realm of landlording. He's a landlord himself with multiple properties. We agreed that since there isn't a rush to get a tenant in place immediately we can test the market to see what I can generate as far as leads with a smaller/higher priced funnel. We didn't want to set the bar too low and regret it later.
From our own comp analysis, we think market rent for this particular unit is closer to $1900. In the vicinity of the property the other homes offload all of the utilities to the tenants. They can list it for a lower price because they have less monthly expenses. Unlike my units where the water isn't individually metered, I would have to take on that expense for both units until I can get that set up with SD Water. I was thinking of using that tactic, list it for a lower price, and have a fixed price for water utilities paid directly to me as part of their expense.