@Vanja Dimitrijevic
1. Is getting a cash out refinance a better way to do it instead of getting a HELOC?
I think a cash out refi would be better. HELOC's are good if maybe you don't have a deal, but want to keep the money ready to use and the property has a low rate that you don't want to lose.
2. In this situation, is it better to get a property through regular means, look what is on the market (through realestate agent), or maybe go through a sheriff sale? We are somewhat handy and would not mind fixing up the house while living in it.
It doesn't matter where you find it as long as the numbers make sense. The better value add deals will typically be off-market.
3. What should I pay attention to if i was to get a property in this situation through an auction?
Most only accept offers with no contingencies so if you're newer it's not the best investment due to the higher risk associated. You can find some diamonds in the rough don't get me wrong but if you aren't experienced enough to see red flags in the property/ transaction they can be costly.
4. Is it better to get an LLC when I become a land lord to get some tax benefits?
I would just stick to buying them in your name. Don't get the cart in front of the wheel. Get a lot of rentals first then worry about it at a later date. If you buy in your name you can buy them with conventional loans as long as you qualify which have better loan terms
If it makes any difference and will better guide your answers, we live in Ohio.
Nice. What part of Ohio?