@Eddie L.
Wow...thanks for the clarification.
I called the Philadelphia tax department a few times, including times when I was on hold for hours until the system abruptly hung up. It's awful!
Anyway, it was 0 help. They told me they can't give me tax advice, they just confirmed that I need to pay the tax and they confirmed that it's normal for it to be in my personal name (with my personal ss#) instead of my llc's ein number, because I am the sole member. She said something about a "disregarded entity"
Anyway, I decided to just add all my income and subtract my expenses and put that magic (unfortunately very low number) on Worksheet B (this is the non-resident one ---- which is another long story...I don't live in Pennsylvania but my LLC's virtual mailbox is there....so not sure if it's resident or non-resident...but since they are using my personal ss# instead of ein I figure it's non resident....the difference is so minor though, so i'm tempted to file as resident just to avoid any hassle)
Do any other cities have this ridiculous additional tax on investment properties? The hassle of getting a rental license and this additional cost makes Philadelphia less desirable for investment. Also, they make it so difficult for people like me who want to do everything right but are having a hard time understanding/following the tax rules.