Hey Brian,
First off, congrats on building that equity over the past five years...that's a solid accomplishment. I remember when I was in a similar spot, debating whether to leverage my first rental to acquire another property. The numbers didn't look spectacular at first glance, especially with rising interest rates nibbling at cash flow.
Here's the thing: while your immediate cash flow only bumps up slightly from $1,300 to $1,400, you're doubling your assets. Think of it like planting two trees instead of one...they might not bear a ton of fruit right away, but over time, you'll have a richer harvest. Plus, owning multiple properties spreads out your risk. If one tenant moves out or unexpected repairs pop up, the other property can help cushion the impact.
Of course, more properties mean more responsibilities...double the maintenance and potential headaches. But if your goal is long-term financial freedom, adding another appreciating asset could be a smart move. Rents tend to rise over time, and that extra $100 in cash flow might look a lot better a few years down the road.
Have you considered exploring markets like Austin or Scottsdale? I've noticed investors finding some promising opportunities there despite the current rates, partly because of strong rental demand and growth potential.
At the end of the day, it's about aligning with your long-term goals and comfort level. Maybe run a few scenarios...what if interest rates climb higher, or if property values plateau? It's not a one-size-fits-all answer, but hopefully this gives you some food for thought.
Whatever path you choose, I'm here rooting for your success.
Jasper & Pat
Turning investment visions into REALITY in Phoenix, AZ - Ranked #1 for residential real estate growth and opportunity by PwC