Hey Mat,
I completely understand where you’re coming from, and I think you're asking the right questions here. First off, kudos for the careful thought you're putting into this decision! The last thing anyone wants is to jump into something that could put them in a tough spot, and you're showing a lot of restraint, which is a big plus.
Let me tell you a little story from my early years in real estate, which might give you a clearer picture. I was once in a similar situation low cash flow, lots of desire to get out of my parent's place, and the temptation to jump on a deal that seemed too good to pass up. I ended up stretching myself thinner than I should’ve, not accounting for some unexpected repairs and the challenges of managing a rental property with little experience. It wasn’t the worst outcome, but it definitely taught me to be cautious and to make sure I wasn't taking on more risk than I could comfortably handle.
In your case, you've got some solid pros here, especially with your savings cushion. But, I'd caution against overextending yourself, especially with the debt you've mentioned. While it's true that you're not paying any interest on that credit card debt at the moment, it's still something to factor into your overall financial health. On top of that, if the HOA has no reserves, you might be looking at some unexpected fees down the road, and the previous buyer's financing falling through might hint at deeper issues with the property.
The idea of buying the place, renting it out, and then moving in later could work, but you should ask yourself: do you feel confident managing a rental property from a distance, especially with your current income situation? As for taking out an additional loan on top of the purchase price, that’s another layer of risk that could come back to bite you down the line. Real estate can be a fantastic wealth-building tool, but the first property should be more about stability and long-term gains rather than short-term sacrifices.
Here’s what I would suggest: If you're really set on making a move now, maybe find a way to negotiate that price down..maybe a little under $230K, even if they won’t budge much. Otherwise, I’d consider sitting tight and building up even more reserves before diving into such a big commitment. I know the market’s moving, but patience is a virtue in real estate. With your current situation, I'd err on the side of caution, and I think you’ll be in a much stronger position in six months or a year.
But here's a question for you: Have you considered other areas of South Florida where you might find a better deal, or perhaps even something that's a little less on your plate in terms of potential headaches?
Let’s keep the conversation going, there are a lot of ways to approach this.