@Sean OToole - Great insights. I heard you speak at Robert Hall & Associates last year and it was impressive. Nice to have your factual expertise.
@Jay Hinrichs - Always entertaining and enlightening. Very interesting summary of troubled borrowers continuing to be trouble borrowers, even after a fresh start. I guess that's why approximately 75% of loan modifications fail within 2 years.
@Steve Vaughan I have spoken directly with the bank and they are just want the borrower to pay the outstanding balance and continue making payments.
@Jon Holdman - Thanks. Your reply reminds me of an Oprah quote. "When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time" Jay's experience of 90% failure confirms this theory.
@Cara Lonsdale The Quit Claim Deed idea was an "insurance policy" if the borrower didn't perform. Creative idea, but as pointed out in this thread there are many issues with this approach. As long as there is substantial equity and overages at the end of the sale, wouldn't a second position lender also be made whole if the asset is taken back and sold?
@Jacob Rhein Creative idea.. I don't think there would be time in this scenario, but it's a good idea on how raise small amounts of capital, especially since HML doesn't seem to be a solution.
The borrowers father built the house, so there is an emotional attachment. He is an only child and his parents have both died in the last 5 years. Borrower offered to pay me 30% ROI, but the issue is, it's illegal, because it's usury, so if I would have to foreclose, an attorney could protect the borrower, and I'd be the bad guy.
Seems like a straight loan is the safest solution. However, at the end of the day there isn't much upside at 10% interest on a $20K loan and plenty of downside risk. Thanks to all for a fascinating and educational thread!
@Joshua Dorkin - You've built an incredible community!