Hey Tariq,
I personally have 3 properties here, 2 of which are short term rentals, so happy to speak to investing in STRs here. I am an also an agent that niches specifically to STR investment properties, so happy to offer detailed insight.
I love investing in short term rentals here - I have one that does over $85k gross a year, one that does over $75k gross a year. It has been life changing for me! I purchased both STR houses in the low-600s range. There are absolutely areas where you can beat a 10% cap rate - I see it all the time - you just need to know where to look and what types of properties perform best.
Some areas I would check out include Bailey, Arvada, Westminster, unincorporated Adams County, and many more I could point you to beyond that. The regulatory environment is the first thing you should consider when buying a STR here - it is both the worst and best part of being a CO STR investor. It is the worst because you need to understand the patchwork of regulations across the state, which can vary down to a neighborhood by neighborhood basis. This is also the best thing, because many out of state investors find it confusing and stay away, which keeps our returns much higher and wards off Wall Street investors from buying up swaths of houses, which we've seen in other markets.As an STR specialist, keeping up with zoning and regulation statewide is a huge part of my job.
I also host monthly short term rental events for local investors, monthly webinars, and I also often get furnished, turnkey off-market STR properties. A lot of STR investors prefer to sell off-market so they don't have to shut off business during tours, and I'm lucky to get access to a large majority of those deals in CO. I definitely recommend connecting with an STR community in the CO area, because it's great to meet other people doing the same thing and bounce ideas off of one another. Feel free to shoot me an email if interested in coming to one of my events - I have several upcoming, happy to shoot you an invite.
Last point I will make - while cap rate is helpful, I prefer using cash on cash return. I find it more helpful to track on my total cash into the deal (inclusive of furniture, amenities, etc), so cash on cash and monthly net cash flow are the two metrics I find are most informative when I'm looking at a purchase.
Liv