Thanks everyone for your input! To answer some of the above questions:
1. Here's my listing. Open to suggestions! https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/5...
2. My original estimates came from AirDNA. I calculated a target of $200/night with a 70% occupancy rate, although my break even point is $175/night with a 55% occupancy rate. PM did not provide any expectations going in.
3. Here are my real numbers in 2022: 51% occupancy rate (roughly 65% in Winter and 35% in Summer), $2907/mo gross rent ($175/night), $1131/mo mortgage, $523/mo PM fees (18% of gross rent), $441/mo insurance, $285/mo repairs, $200/mo electric/gas, $150/mo landscaping, $120/mo property taxes, $115/mo supplementary STR insurance, $80/mo water/garbage. So my recurring monthly costs are about $3,045.
4. I'm not going to manage it myself. I have two other business that take precedence and I live in Mexico, so that's not on the table. I allocated a couple of hours per week to manage this RE business.
5. I'm using a PM that lists on multiple booking sites, although they don't tell me which sites were used for my bookings.
Since digging into the numbers to supply the above figures, I think I should:
A. Re-run the AirDNA numbers. I haven't looked since Summer 2021. Maybe the market changed.
B. Possibly cancel the supplementary STR insurance. I don't know if it's necessary.
Further suggestions appreciated!