@Brian Garrett, sorry I didn't see your post. This is going to be long, so get comfortable.
There are only two types of investments, regardless of the asset class (real estate, stocks, bonds, etc.):
- Appreciation: Buy low and sell high (real estate flips fall into this category)
- Cash flow: Buy and hold and receive cash flow (monthly, quarterly or annually)
Let's look at each one. You can buy a $100,000 asset that will appreciate in value 10% in one year, or you can buy a $100,000 asset that will generate 10% cash flow each year. Does it matter which one you buy if they both will generate $10,000 at the end of the year? The main difference are the opportunity costs. With the appreciation deal, you will get back your $100,000 and have the opportunity to reinvest it in something that may generate more than 10%. You can always find an appreciation investment that will generate a greater annual return than a buy and hold investment. It's the nature of the beast (more risk, greater return). There is usually more risk associated with an appreciation investment, but if you know how to manage and shift risk, you can create a low risk / high reward investment.
It's hard to create a low risk / high reward buy and hold investments. First, in order to generate the 10% annual return, you must keep your $100,000 invested in the investment. Sure you can borrow against it, but there are costs associated with accessing your equity in the investment. For real estate, those costs are pretty steep compared to the cost of selling an asset that has appreciated in order to get you $100,000 back. Plus, you aren't going to get to borrow the entire $100,000 you put into the investment. Next, your ability to sustain that 10% annual return is based on the rental market, your vacancy rate, and your maintenance and capex expenses. You also have to look at your return on equity as your property appreciates. At some point you will realize that your return on equity is lower than the return you would get if you sold the property and purchased a new (to you) buy and hold investment (please Google if you don't understand what I'm saying).
So, appreciation investments will always produce greater returns than buy and hold investments, but they also have greater risks. Once you know how to manage and shift those risks (and leverage is one of the ways), you create a low risk / high reward investment.
People who trade with stock options (calls and puts) do this every day. The market is so liquid and the transactions costs (especially compared to real estate) are so low, that appreciation deals are easy to do. A call option is the perfect example of using leverage for an appreciation investment. You can buy an "" call option contract for $2.18/share for the SPY - SPDR S&P 500 FTE that closed today at $235.54/share. That's a 1:108 leverage ratio. That means for ever 1% increase in the underlying asset (an increase of $2.36/share), the call option contract will increase by 108% (also $2.36/share). It's hard to find greater leverage than stock options (but you can find them in real estate). Now let's apply this to real estate.
You purchase a $100,000 property using 1:10 leverage (10%) or $10,000. If the property increases by 1% ($1,000), your equity in the property increases by $1,000 (or 10%). This is the power of leverage. It allows your equity position to increase dollar for dollar with any increase in the underlying asset, but since you are levered, the dollar increase is magnified by your leverage ratio. So how do you combine a leverage ratio of more than 1:100 with real estate appreciation investments? Simple, they are called Pre-Construction Flips.
New home builders allow you to use leverage to control their properties. In CA, you can control a $500,000 purchase contract with only $5,000 down (EMD). It takes the builder 4-6 months to complete the house. Say the value of the properties in the market go up 1% per month (this is happening in many markets across the country, and definitely in southern CA). So in 6 months the value of the contract has increased by 6%, or $30,000. You now have $25,000 of equity in your contract (that's a 500% increase). and you only risked $5,000. How many of you would risk $5,000 to make $25,000 in 6 months? It's all based on your risk tolerance.
You can do something similar when you wholesale and put a house under contract a long closing period (60-90 days) in a fast appreciating market. But those deals require hard work to find (I don't like working hard, I like working smart). The first Pre-Construction Flip I did was in 2004, where I put a house under contract for $418,000 in May 2003 for only $3,000 (1:139 leverage). The builder took 18 months to build my house and when I closed on 9/8/2004 (a day before my 33rd birthday), it was worth $600,000. That's a $182,000 increase. The equity in my contract increased by 6,067%, or an annualized rate of 4,044%. THAT'S THE POWER OF LEVERAGE!
PM me if you have any specific questions about Pre-ConstructionFflips or using leverage in general.
Stay Blessed!