I own a duplex in Fort Pierce Florida. I have a new Section 8 tenant in one of my units and she recently contacted me to inform me that there is a crack in the tub that is leaking water onto the bathroom floor. I immediately contacted a couple of contractors to get bids/advice on the best way to fix the problem. One suggested a new tub but explained that it would involve tearing up current bathroom to remove tub before putting a replacement in. That person's time estimate of that job would be a minimum of 7 days to complete. The other contractor repairs the existing tub, guarantees the work for 3 years, and the job takes 2 hours to do but the tub has to sit untouched for 3 days in order to harden. I choose the quicker, less expensive route of tub repair.
Because my tenant would not be able to use the tub for 3 days while it dried, I made reservations and paid for a hotel for her to stay in. The tenant told me that any hotel I choose should be close to the freeway because she doesn't have a car and the person she rides to work with wants her close to the freeway. I went on line and did a google search for hotels near the freeway in Fort Pierce. The closest one was a Motel 6 and cost $50 a night. I reserved the room for my tenant and her 2 children. When I contacted my tenant to tell her the arrangements she said she wouldn't stay at a Motel 6 because she has not had a good experience with them, she didn't feel comfortable taking her kids there, and she wanted something with a stove since she wants to cook during the 3 days. I said ok but since I had found a hotel for $50/ a night that if she choose something else more expensive that I would pay $50 a night and anything over that she could pay. She said that she couldn't afford anything and that I should be the whole thing at a hotel which costs $65 a night.
1. Am I required to pay the hotel bill if she can't use her tub?
2. Can I choose the cheapest acceptable hotel?
3. Her water is working she can still do wash ups while the tub is drying should I tell her to kick rocks?
I'd appreciate input and feedback from other landlords who have been in this position. Thanks in advance.