Quote from @Steven Wesolowski:
If your intent is to not sell and continue to hold, then I would look for making the tenant as happy as possible. I am not 100% sure what your relationship to your tenant is, but if they are the type where they understand you would have to take on the burden of the additional cost in necessary repairs, and they feel they can continue to be a long-term tenant because you are helping them, then on the bright side at least you will still have rental money coming in.
But help me help you dissect your situation:
You've already done $30k rehab, and already informed at least $10k debt addition highly probable. How much are you currently cash flowing ? What is dollar amount still cash flowing if you actually do the repairs?
Dependent on the lease contract, of course; have the tenants expressed readiness to leave if you don't fix the problem? If so, what date will they press to leave your property? How much will they pay you to leave your property?
Your mortgage rate at 5% currently, what type of loan is this? Was this through credit union or bank? How much do you still have owed on paying off the house right now?
DM me your details and reply here. I am confident you will get various responses before New Years. Now is the time to take a knee and re-assess, mitigate your risk. Start planning for first quarter 2024 right now.
First off, yes! This is 100% a property I was planning on keeping long-term as a buy-and-hold asset. Which is why I'm so tempted to get the loan, since 2 to 3 years are nothing compared to the rest of my life. Here are my numbers:
Cashflow: $578.54 (this excludes the payments to the current debt, which is on 0% interest for 15 more months)
- Paying $200/mo as minimum payments, and I estimate to have personal reserves to pay off this debt at the end of the 15 month period so it doesn't accrue any interest.
- That leaves me with $378.54/mo cashflow right now. I don't have the number in front of me, but if I take the loan for the sump pump, it was roughly $325/mo for the monthly payment.
The tenant and I have a good relationship. I was upfront with her and told her this was something I was not prepared for and would have to do a bit of digging for a solution. I told her that I'd understand if this was something she didn't want to deal with and preferred to leave. She told me she would let me know if that would be the course she takes, but no timeline yet. If she leaves before the lease term ends, I would keep the $1400 deposit. Since this is an issue on my end for foundation, I don't think it would pass for me to have a certain amount of payments given to me (other than the deposit) if she chooses to leave.
The mortgage is 5.375%. It's with a Financial Institution called Specialized Loan Servicing (SLS). I put a 5% down payment on the house as a primary residence, which is how I was able to work on it for 15 months.
- Purchase price $125.9k
- Remaining Balance: $117,673.11
- ARV: Not sure on this one since I haven't had any appraisals, but without accounting for any repairs on the house, the value went up to $132k over the 15 months.
Thank you very much for your help!