Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Axel Scaggs

Axel Scaggs has started 5 posts and replied 19 times.

Post: Making a mistake with a cash-out refinance?

Axel Scaggs
Posted
  • Investor
  • Denton, TX
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Jay Hurst:
Quote from @Axel Scaggs:
Quote from @Patrick Roberts:
Quote from @Axel Scaggs:
Quote from @Alan Lacey:

I would certainly recommend shopping that around a bit just to make sure that is best available. Assuming dscr because that would be too much in fees to be allowed on a conventional deal

It is a conventional cash-out refinance on an investment property I own. My W-2 was required to meet dti.

I actually went through a broker recommended here by several people on BP. 

This is conventional? Yeah, you definitely need to get another quote. This would be reasonable for a DSCR with a short PPP and FICO below 700. If this is conventional, the lender fees are ridiculous.

This loan should be somewhere around 7.125 - 7.375 at worst with a decent FICO while going borrower-paid. I could see this quote being realistic if it was lender-paid and you werent having to pay the broker out of pocket. Total loan fees (not including broker commission) should be at or under $2,500; maybe $2,700 at worst. Even below 700 FICO, you should be at or under par at 7.5% on borrower-paid and under 75% LTV, not paying points.

I appreciate the the feedback. My FICO is a 770 and the LTV I believe was over 75%. It’s unfortunate, but I guess I learned the importance of shopping around as I only talked with one other lender. If I’m locked into this, I’ll just be much more careful in the future.

 @Axel Scaggs  You are NOT locked in until you sign the closing documents. Assuming you credit score is 770 that is an awful loan, and you should NOT close with those terms. 


Ok thank you for the advice, I’ll look elsewhere. What is a generally expected closing cost on a loan of that amount? I was expecting $7-10k. Second, would this lender modify the fees if I presented a competing offer? Or is that not a typical thing to do.

Post: Making a mistake with a cash-out refinance?

Axel Scaggs
Posted
  • Investor
  • Denton, TX
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Patrick Roberts:
Quote from @Axel Scaggs:
Quote from @Alan Lacey:

I would certainly recommend shopping that around a bit just to make sure that is best available. Assuming dscr because that would be too much in fees to be allowed on a conventional deal

It is a conventional cash-out refinance on an investment property I own. My W-2 was required to meet dti.

I actually went through a broker recommended here by several people on BP. 

This is conventional? Yeah, you definitely need to get another quote. This would be reasonable for a DSCR with a short PPP and FICO below 700. If this is conventional, the lender fees are ridiculous.

This loan should be somewhere around 7.125 - 7.375 at worst with a decent FICO while going borrower-paid. I could see this quote being realistic if it was lender-paid and you werent having to pay the broker out of pocket. Total loan fees (not including broker commission) should be at or under $2,500; maybe $2,700 at worst. Even below 700 FICO, you should be at or under par at 7.5% on borrower-paid and under 75% LTV, not paying points.

I appreciate the the feedback. My FICO is a 770 and the LTV I believe was over 75%. It’s unfortunate, but I guess I learned the importance of shopping around as I only talked with one other lender. If I’m locked into this, I’ll just be much more careful in the future.

Post: Making a mistake with a cash-out refinance?

Axel Scaggs
Posted
  • Investor
  • Denton, TX
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 7

I may be too far along in the process to back out now. I’m not super familiar with refinances, but I’d assume there’s a grace period to pull out and I have probably passed that by now.

Post: Making a mistake with a cash-out refinance?

Axel Scaggs
Posted
  • Investor
  • Denton, TX
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Alan Lacey:

I would certainly recommend shopping that around a bit just to make sure that is best available. Assuming dscr because that would be too much in fees to be allowed on a conventional deal

It is a conventional cash-out refinance on an investment property I own. My W-2 was required to meet dti.

I actually went through a broker recommended here by several people on BP. 

Post: Making a mistake with a cash-out refinance?

Axel Scaggs
Posted
  • Investor
  • Denton, TX
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 7
Quote from @AJ Exner:
Quote from @Axel Scaggs:
Quote from @Patrick Roberts:

Couple questions -

What's the rate and remaining life of the $130k first position?

For the closing costs, how much of that was escrows? If you're currently escrowing with the existing first lien, you would be refunded the balance of that escrow account about a month or so after closing on the new loan.


 The original loan rate was high, at 8.75%, new rate is 7.5%. House was purchased in 2017, so restarting it has certainly affected things in that regard. I attached images of the closing costs. 


$10k in Origination is tough, ~3.5 points + lender fee sounds like did the heavy lifting, plus title/prop tax in TX can add up quickly.

As for the numbers, I think its easier to regret not selling in the short term, but the hope is for long-term gains/appreciation. If they can cover your mortgage and you can slowly payoff a 350k property over time, that should give you a good equity position in no time.

Plus, if rates get better that will always help. 30k-40k + Cash-out proceeds should put you in a great spot to snatch up a few of those 30-50k properties to fix up and scale.

I wouldn't be upset, sounds like you are in a good spot.


 Thanks so much for your feedback! I suppose I’ll just be happy retaining the original asset and see what I can do to build with the funds I’ve taken out. 

Post: Making a mistake with a cash-out refinance?

Axel Scaggs
Posted
  • Investor
  • Denton, TX
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Patrick Roberts:

Couple questions -

What's the rate and remaining life of the $130k first position?

For the closing costs, how much of that was escrows? If you're currently escrowing with the existing first lien, you would be refunded the balance of that escrow account about a month or so after closing on the new loan.


 The original loan rate was high, at 8.75%, new rate is 7.5%. House was purchased in 2017, so restarting it has certainly affected things in that regard. I attached images of the closing costs. 

Post: Making a mistake with a cash-out refinance?

Axel Scaggs
Posted
  • Investor
  • Denton, TX
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 7

I recently started the process of doing a cash-out refinance on my single investment property. It cash-flows at $700 a month. Mortgage balance is $130,000. Appraised at $357k, although past appraisals have been higher. The max amount they approved to be pulled out was $123k. This makes the property break even. I only have $30-40k though, so I’ve felt stuck with this single property.

I wanted to use the cash to do some fix and flips and in the rare event a BRRRR presented itself early on, go that route and then continue with fix and flips. The market I'm looking at has plenty of houses in the 30-50k range that could be fixed. However, I'm wondering if I should have simply sold my investment property and used the full $220k-ish I would have had then. Was my move probably the least effective method?

P.S.: I also did not enjoy the $18k in closing on this number. Insanely high from what I was expecting.

Post: Subject To deal while in underwriting for personal investment property

Axel Scaggs
Posted
  • Investor
  • Denton, TX
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Shiloh Lundahl:

This is such an interesting question. And I don't think it is as clear cut as people are saying. I get a lot of loans every year and the questions depend on the bank the and the loan officer.

Currently I am looking at getting a US based loan on a property that I own in Costa Rica. They are doing their underwriting process. They know that I own a lot of real estate, but they are only asking me questions about properties that I own where the initial debt was was taken out in my own name (qualifying loans or non-DSCR loans) before I transferred them into LLCs. Those are the only properties I need to give a specific accounting for as far as my debt goes. They use the rent payments to offset the debt if I have rented the properties for a couple of years. All the other real estate in my businesses are counted as assets minus the debt liabilities for net worth purposes and the business income that comes to me is counted as part of my personal income. It really depends on the bank and the banker.

The best is to work with a seasoned banker who knows the system well and knows which questions to ask investors and which not to ask investors. Because, for instance, if I am flipping a couple of properties and I am in the middle of the rehab, but it will take a couple of months for them to get finished and sold, I may be paying $4000 on hard money debt payments per month, and if that debt is included in whether or not I will qualify for a refinance, then I may not qualify. Even though those debts are temporary. So my loan officer may direct me to not disclose those properties while applying for the refinance.  

If something is disclosed then it will be counted against you so just ask the loan officer some qualifying questions to see what you need to disclose. Questions such as:

- What type of real estate do you want me to disclose?

- Do you want me to disclose real estate owned in my own name or real estate owned in my businesses too if my businesses qualified for the debt? 

- Do you want me to disclose real estate that I may own if the debt was guanenteed by someone else? Etc.

You both want to make the loan happen so just ask questions and then disclose according to what the loan officer directs you to disclose.  If while asking the questions the loan officer says that the sub to property that you are getting ready to buy would become an issue then just close on the sub to property after you close on your refinance. 

Thank you for the different perspective! It sounds like I just need to be transparent with the loan officer. I will probably wait until the loan is finalized to do anything to be on the safe side regardless this time. I feel like the seller would wait and I could just buy it in cash since I do plan to refinance it anyway and pull out the equity once I’ve done some repairs/upgrades. I know a lot of people want to make the seller hold the property 2-5 years in their name, but I don’t feel like that is very fair to the seller.

Post: Subject To deal while in underwriting for personal investment property

Axel Scaggs
Posted
  • Investor
  • Denton, TX
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Jay Hurst:
Quote from @Axel Scaggs:

I recently found a Subject To deal that works for me. However, I'm in the middle of a cash-out refinance of an investment property I already own. My question is, if I was to proceed with the Subject To deal, will this somehow be discovered? Am I better off just waiting until the refinance is complete? I wasn't really sure how it would pop up, but don't see a reason to risk things and complicate my cash-out.


 It would "pop up" because you do not want to commit mortgage fraud. 

Thank you for the response. I wasn’t sure how that would all work considering I wasn’t taking on debt per se, but there is indeed a promise to make payments on the mortgage. Definitely want to do things right, sorry if it seemed like I was trying to skirt around the law 👍🏻

Post: Subject To deal while in underwriting for personal investment property

Axel Scaggs
Posted
  • Investor
  • Denton, TX
  • Posts 19
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Brandon Croucier:

What kind of refinance are you doing?


 A cash-out refinance on a different property I own unrelated to the Subject To deal.