Hi @Kyle Wise
I personally think condos can be a good option for STR. I have 2 in Myrtle beach and they have cashflowed very well. You have to look at all the numbers and know the right buildings to invest in. You definitely do not want to use onsite management. They have a 60/40 split here, and that means you don't make money. I purchased my condos in a building that doesn't have a resort manager onsite. I manage my properties myself and that helps with the cash flow. At first I was a little cautious about the high HOA fee, but when you see what it includes, it makes sense. My HOA includes all the electric, water, cable, internet etc so I just have one bill I pay every month and it is predictable. I bought my properties right after they had an assessment, so I got the benefit of an upgraded building without having to pay the assessment. The biggest sticking factor is the financing on a condotel. Most large banks don't finance them. However, there are other options out there and you can get financing if you know the right people. Condo's typically don't appreciate as well as houses, however, my condo's have doubled in value this last year. Appreciation is a bonus for me with my investments. If it cashflows and appreciates, that is a win win.
Get with an agent who specializes in the area and knows the ins and outs. Give it a try! Having a condo and a SFH would be great, then you can start putting together your own data to see which one performs better. At the end of the day, having an ocean front condo that you and your guests can see and smell the ocean is not a bad option. Good luck!