I was not part of the Virginia development but bought into one of their deals in Dyersburg, TN. It's the exact same story, just with numbers about half of what the OP had (purchase price $55k, down payment $30k). Mine was not in an IRA, so I guess I could take the loss if I walked away. This was before I was doing this full-time. I would NEVER even consider this house today. I actually forgot I still need to deal with this headache...
My tenant is a long term tenant. He was there before I bought the house and still is and has always paid the same price. So it is odd that the price that GEG told me my rent was in the pro-forma was 25% higher than what was being paid and increasing every year. When I spoke with the property manager they said there is no way I could get more than I was getting without significant work and upgrades to the house. To be fair, I think they were probably put in a tough situation.
When I talked to GEG about it they give some excuse about how they give you a one-time payment for the first year differences 6-months into ownership. Ignoring the fact that the ENTIRE BASIS of the purchases is predicated on the rent being what they stated. This IS in their paperwork, but as you are signing it you are thinking "who cares, the rent is what you told me it is". In other words, they aren't super clear on the fact that they are just basically making up numbers on the pro-forma, not even the current rent, which they DO have, is used.
Their pro-forma is a real piece of work. I mean it's a wonderland for people who like to play in Excel all day, but it's just pencil-whipping a property. Value is built up around assumed appreciation.
Does anyone have an interest in seeing the paperwork from this deal (with personal information removed obviously)?