This is why I love real estate! So many different ways to solve the same problem of building wealth.
Boiling down the questions and answers provided above:
Property is near Ann Arbor Michigan, Ypsilanti to be exact. Insert keyword alert here. Hi Ann Arbor investors!
Taxes in Ypsi are the 2nd highest in the state, 2nd only to Ann Arbor, making it tough to cash flow a rental unless you absolutely buy it right. (Ann Arbor just passed a billion dollar bond for school improvements. Great for my kids, terrible for my wallet.)
I am secretly in love with multi family apartment buildings but I have very few connections with multi family investors. If I cash it out, I'd have about 180-190k left over to reinvest which would make an awesome 1031 I presume. @Adam Leitman Bailey thanks for pointing me down that route.
Holding the property and letting values increase seems risky both because of the sheer law of averages on our market curve, and also due to the limiting factors of our high taxes.
I have to confess that I spent a long time in the HELOC zone. I love the idea of not making payments on a debt unless I'm using it.
@Greg H. it's been a rental since 2004. Our basis is high at 180k. Kind of a long story, but we bought a tiny terrible house and fell in love with making it our dream home. First house, ya know. :) Also the house is definitely local to us. That said, I have been looking around at other markets trying to get a feel for where I could invest. (@Dave Foster) :)
Ok, more to consider. I'll reread these all and make some connections.
Thanks again everyone. What a community!