Thank you all for taking the time to advise me! @Brandon Turner @Doug S.
@Albert Bui . Thank you especially for pointing out the tax ramifications - I wasn't aware of how the standard deduction worked along with mortgage interest. Last year, I had about $21K in mortgage interest and another $8K in property taxes. That is definitely something to take into account!
Here is some more information on my home and what I have modeled out in terms of investment property.
The monthly PITI on my house is $3700. It is worth about $850K and I have a 30 yr fixed loan for $550K. The rent for a similar home in the area is about $3200. The issue I have is the location (Orange County CA) and the price I initially paid for my house. I can't rent it out to cover my PITI (plus I'd have to cover maintenance, vacancy, etc. on top of that). If I could rent it for cash flow, I definitely would! However, we play to sell within the year and either buy another primary residence that better fits our needs or buy an investment property and use the cash flow to pay for our rent - that's the choice we've given ourselves.
So, if we did go the investment route, I was thinking that I would invest out of state where the cap rates are much higher and gain enough cash flow to live almost rent free (I think I would need a cap rate of about 10% on a $700K or $800K property). We currently own 2 4plexes in Boise, but that market is very difficult for us out of staters to purchase anything good right now - at least, my contacts there haven't been able to identify the kind of investment I would be looking for. So I need to find a different city to look in (any suggestions?).
This is what I modeled out (below).
Downpayment
|
25%
|
# of Units
|
15
|
Lease Amount
|
562,500
|
Purchase
|
750,000
|
Annual Interest Rate
|
4.75%
|
Downpayment
|
187,500
|
Period
|
360
|
Rent/Unit
|
700
|
Monthly Payments
|
$2,934
|
|
|
Rent
|
10,500
|
Vacancy @10%
|
(1,050)
|
Mgmt @10%
|
(1,050)
|
Repairs/Reserve @8%
|
(840)
|
Utilities
|
(300)
|
P&I
|
(2,934)
|
Insurance
|
(83)
|
Property Tax @2.5%
|
(1,250)
|
Net Monthly
|
2,992
|
2% Rule
|
1.4%
|
Cash Flow
|
199
|
50% Rule
|
154
|
Total Investment
|
187,500
|
ROI
|
24%
|
Monthly Cash
|
2,992
|
Cap Rate
|
9.5%
|
I think a seasoned investor could probably do a lot better, but I want to realistic about what I might be able to find in the market. What do you think of my numbers? What have I missed and do you think if I were to buy an investment that worked out like this, would it be a good idea to go for it instead of buying another primary residence? Any suggestions for cities/locations where I might be able to find a somewhat hands off investment like this (I would have to hire a manager because I would still live in CA)?
Thanks again for looking at this post! I understand if you don't have time to look at this as closely as I have (we're all busy), but any suggestions would be appreciated!