Hey @Dan Beaulieu! Good to talk to you again and I appreciate the insight!
During our initial conversation I asked her why she was wanting to sell. Her response was that they are getting older and would like to have the money. He concern however was her long term tenant. She spoke in detail on how she was not wanted to leave her stranded. So I've been trying to structure offers that satisfy those concerns. Not so easy...
So I came up with 3 offers this morning. Being that they are in their early 60s I was trying to keep the terms at 10 years or less. I was also trying to incorporate concessions for the current tenant who is currently paying $725 where the average rent (for that same size home) is $1500+. So I unfortunately will not be able to keep her there.
Comps: Fully renovated ~$300k. Similar properties in a "As-is" ~$230k
Offer #1: ARV $290,700k ($255/sqft) x .70 = $203,490 – $53,490 (repairs) = $150k
- Seller: Pro – Get all cash up front. Con – Decreased purchased price and captain gains hit.
- Buyer: Pro – Decreased purchase price. Con – Large capital outlay in purchase and repair. Higher risk flip.
- Tenant: Pro – 30 Days to vacate and a $725 buyer credit. Con – Must leave in 30 days
Offer #2: Purchase at $200k – 20k down and $180k in 5 years
- Seller: Pro – Some cash up front. Con – No more cash until year 5
- Buyer: Pro – Less money upfront. Con – Capital outlay of repair to get higher price in rent
- Tenant: Pro – 60 Days to vacate. Con – No seller credit
Offer #3: $228k - $40,500 down = $187,500 then $1500/mo after 90 days for 125 months
- Seller: Pro – Good amount of cash up front. Premium Price. More than double rent monthly. Deferred taxes. Con – Payout is 125 months
- Buyer: Pro – Marginal amount upfront. Payment plan. Con – Not buying below market value.
- Tenant: Pro – 90 Days to vacate. Con – Still having to move
The seller and I spoke again last night. We are going to have lunch week after next in St. Augustine, FL. We just happen to be there at the same time. Wish me luck!!!