Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 16%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$39 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Matthew Samson

Matthew Samson has started 7 posts and replied 23 times.

Post: Roughly How Much Property To Buy To Create $200k in Paper Losses?

Matthew Samson
Posted
  • Posts 23
  • Votes 16

Thanks all for your help! We're absolutely in the 37% tax bracket, and very much subscribers to the present vs future value of money. Any future transactions would be done via 1031 exchange, to kick the can down the road as long as we can (/ forever). 

Given our high W2 cashflow, the idea is to take aggressive year 1 depreciation on a succession of new purchases, at least until we've offsite a lot of my wife's taxable income.  

Sean, I'd love to see your calculator. Looking forward to connecting!

The short term rental loophole is definitely intriguing; just worried a bit about the 500 hr time commitment with a full time W2 job (and a newborn). Also, is it overkill to put all 500 hours into just one property? Would that raise IRS eyebrows?

Will take y'alls advice to connect with a CPA to get into the details.

Thanks again! 

Post: Roughly How Much Property To Buy To Create $200k in Paper Losses?

Matthew Samson
Posted
  • Posts 23
  • Votes 16

Hey all. My wife is a doctor, and we have an opportunity to offset a lot of her taxable income this year if I qualify for Real Estate Professional Status. However, I could also continue working my W2 and claim what deductions we can whilst keeping real estate investing as a passive activity.

We've worked out that we would need to create $200,000 in additional paper losses this year to fully offset my lost W2 income from becoming a real estate professional. My question is, roughly how much real estate would we need to buy to create these paper losses, assuming we take full advantage of the tax code? This includes current 20% bonus depreciation, cost segregation, mortgage interest, property tax, etc. etc. 

I'm just looking for a general rule of thumb, and fine using general assumptions like the 1% rule, national averages for property taxes, etc. etc. I understand that actual calculations are highly specific to the property in question. 

Post: Borderline (expensive) foundation problem

Matthew Samson
Posted
  • Posts 23
  • Votes 16

Thanks Laura and everyone for the help! After multiple quotes, some great advice here, and an engineer inspection, we decided to repair the foundation with an external pier system. Here is our rationale, in case anyone else encounters a similar problem. 

- In our Georgia home, when it was new the warranty would have covered settling up to 1/4 inch. That ours is 3/4 inch out suggested settling since the warranty passed and/or a serious enough issue to remedy. 

- Drainage patterns and erosion around the foundation were consistent with the settling we saw, suggesting the slab foundation had been continuously undermined throughout the 23-year life of the house. 

- We plan on holding the property as a long-term rental, and the amortized cost of the repairs is marginal. The house will continue to be an excellent investment.  

What we learned: We got lucky that we gained a lot of extra equity soon after we bought the house, which makes these repairs palatable. When buying the house, we made the mistake of getting an inspector recommended by our realtor who seemed credible and detail-oriented but I think just wanted to get us into the house. Whilst there were no obvious structural issues caused by the settling, the evidence was there for a trained and impartial eye to see. In addition, I will also be paying much closer attention to water flow patterns and signs of erosion around our next investment!  

Post: Borderline (expensive) foundation problem

Matthew Samson
Posted
  • Posts 23
  • Votes 16

Hi Rick. Thanks so much for your reply! We're definitely in an area know for regular settling. The problem does appear to be somewhat old, but still thinking it might be worth it given this is a long term investment that would still be netting us a really solid YoY return.

Definitely getting a 3rd opinion/bid now. A tough thing we've found though (like you mentioned) is even the highly rated foundation folks in our area -- as well as a lot of the content online -- all have a strong incentive to sell big high-margin solutions. It's hard to decide what's a reasonable solution.  

Post: Borderline (expensive) foundation problem

Matthew Samson
Posted
  • Posts 23
  • Votes 16

Thanks Chris, that's really helpful! It's in the main area of the home, and the intention is to keep it as a long-term rental, so I agree that addressing the issue might be the best course of action. 

Post: Borderline (expensive) foundation problem

Matthew Samson
Posted
  • Posts 23
  • Votes 16

We plan to turn our current house hack into a long term rental. We just discovered a crack in the concrete slab foundation that is a borderline major problem:
- It is a vertical crack about 1/8 inch wide that is at least 9ft long, which is causing a 3/4 inch drop in the flooring and some evidence of old (luckily) limited moisture and termite intrusion. 
- BUT, it also appears old and probably a symptom of the original house settling. It has not caused any noticeable structural issues. We know that some settling is inevitable on all slabs. 

The options we have are: 
- Do nothing and keep monitoring the crack.
- Seal the crack only from above and hope it stays static.
- Stabilize the foundation with helical piers on the exterior. 

The helical piers system would cost $25k but is a permanent solution. Is it overkill for a potential non-problem? Would the fact that our house is in the ~ $850k valuation range influence your advice? 

Even if you don't feel you have enough info to give me directional advice, how would you go about deciding whether to address the problem? 

Post: Should I engage a CPA now or wait until we've built up a basic portfolio?

Matthew Samson
Posted
  • Posts 23
  • Votes 16

@Cory Vitale @Max Emory Thank you both for your detailed replies and all the great advice! 

Post: Different CPAs for investments in different states?

Matthew Samson
Posted
  • Posts 23
  • Votes 16

Thanks Ben and Diyan. That's really helpful! 

Post: Different CPAs for investments in different states?

Matthew Samson
Posted
  • Posts 23
  • Votes 16

Hi All. Thank you everyone  for engaging on my posts as I ramp up towards my first deal!

My next question is a simple one: through circumstance, we will almost certainly have real estate holdings in two states (Georgia and likely Pennsylvania). Is it advisable to have different CPAs in each state, or should one take care of our entire national portfolio?

I understand that state tax and regulatory conditions can vary quite a bit.  Do the advantages of state-specific expertise offset the added complexity of having multiple CPAs? 
  

Post: Should I engage a CPA now or wait until we've built up a basic portfolio?

Matthew Samson
Posted
  • Posts 23
  • Votes 16

Thanks everyone for your great feedback. It looks like the consensus now is to hold of until we have our first investment. 

That said, there are advantages to engaging a CPA early for the purposes of long-term relationship building and tax strategy planning. 

If I'm understanding correctly, there are also additional tax benefits to fixing up/renovating our primary residence after we have converted it to a rental?

That way we could either claim expenses as deductions or through depreciation, rather than just as an increase in basis for capital gains if it was our primary residence?