Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Matthew Porcaro

Matthew Porcaro has started 8 posts and replied 418 times.

Post: NEWBIE FIRST DEAL-FLIP What is your opinion on these funding strategies? Next steps?

Matthew Porcaro
Lender
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 427
  • Votes 319
Quote from @Tony Pellettieri:
Quote from @Matthew Porcaro:
Quote from @Tony Pellettieri:
Quote from @Kaitlyn Aragon:
Quote from @Matthew Porcaro:
Quote from @Kaitlyn Aragon:
Quote from @Nicholas L.:

@Kaitlyn Aragon

i think i posted in your other thread, but did you rule out house hacking, or a live in flip?  i can't remember.

a big flip is just a very risky way to get started... a house hack or a live in flip are lower risk (not no risk, but lower risk.)

miscellaneous reactions

-you don't buy a flip with a DSCR loan - if you converted it to a BRRRR, you would refi into a DSCR loan.  you'd use the DSCR loan to pay off the hard money loan.

-"if you find the deal the money will find you" - once you're an experienced operator, not on your first.  so yep, don't trust that.  

-no one is going to save you if you buy a bad deal.  you'll have to pay back whatever loan you take out.  say you think you can sell for 300K or whatever the case is, but comps are at 250K when you're done.  that hard money loan is still due.  period.  they couldn't care less that you misread the comps - you'll have to cover whatever the difference is with your own cash.

-the best flips generally are not on market. so if you're looking at on-market deals with an agent... you're probably wasting your time. once a while something will come along and go on the MLS but in general distressed properties are sold off market.

-it's not just about losing money, it's about time and effort.  say you budget for a 3 month rehab and it takes 7 and you break even after you sell.  great, you haven't lost money... but you wasted 7 months.

hope this helps

I did rule out house hacking unless it would be a duplex - which has been proven to be difficult to find here in Charlotte. I did not rule out living in a flip - I am actually looking more into a 203K loan. I don't necessarily love the idea of being tied down to a house for a year but if it is what gets me started then i'm willing. Thanks for that info about the DSCR loan - that makes much more sense. Do you have any suggestions to find more off market properties? I have been put on some wholesalers lists but you have to act very fast and without much time to evaluate the property. 





 I know a year may seem like a long time, but remember real estate investing is a long game. When I got my first duplex using a 203k, especially it being a fixer upper, the renovation alone took almost 8 months to complete. I wasn't in the property very long until I had the ability to refinance and continue on my journey. 

Dollar for dollar its the best way to start and your money will go a lot longer in the long term. 

As far as finding properties off market, I wouldn't focus too much on wholesalsers if you're looking to do a 203k or homestyle reno loan. I'd focus on agent outreach. Go to zillow and sort by lowest prices in your market. Call every single listing agent (include pending sales) and let them know your criteria. Keep them on a list and follow up with them. If there are agents that are receptive, invite them to coffee or a lunch and build those relationships. 

My flipping business was entirely built on agent relationships. At the end of the day they're the ones that get the lowest hanging fruit. 

Other off-market strategies work, but you have to be willing to put the time, money, and effort into sticking with it long enough to see results. 


Hey Matthew, Thanks for your response! I am quickly learning how much of a "long game" REI really is. I have been gaining momentum for three years and I often think if I had just pulled the trigger years ago I would be in a much better position. BUT looking forward. I am glad your 203K investment worked out - gives me hope for mine!

I am currently working with 2 agents and I am looking to reach out to more once my funding is locked in. Thanks for the advise on how to go about that. Relationships have gotten me more movement than any mentorship I've been in so I agree!

203K Loans can be helpful but can take much away from the bottom line as there are many fees, similar to those of a hard money loan, that are incorporated into the loan on the back end for inspections, draws, follow up, etc, often times +/- $10k-$15k, depending on the size of the loan/rehab budget. Just something to be aware of.

Personally, I'd recommend a HM Rehab Loan, over a 203k loan, as the draw fees are usually only around $100 each, and you can send pictures over to the HML to gain access to your draws. As you'll find, traditional financing, especially FHA, can be a real pain in the butt. So many hoops to jump through, and more so for the less savvy real estate investor.

No idea where you're getting $10-15K in "fees" on a 203k. The HUD consultant would be a maximum of about $1500 or so, and that includes the draws and an inspection on the property, and a full creation of a scope of work. A lender is going to charge anywhere between 2-3% in origination points, and that's no different than any other mortgage. Not to mention, all of these fees are wrapable into the loan.

Also, recommending a HML for someone that's new, saying that it's somehow easier than working with an FHA 203k doesn't make much sense. HML's require their borrowers to have experience in construction or flipping, where a 203k does not. The reason for the few extra pieces of paperwork is to help people with no experience have a more controlled process. I worked in large construction in NYC for over 10 years. Everything required on a 203k is how every construction project should be handled. Having a clear scope of work, a vetted, licensed and insured contractor, and someone to objectively inspect the work is not a "pain", its how every project should be handled.

But the biggest most glaring difference, is you only need 3.5% down on an FHA 203k. On a HML with someone with little experience, you're looking at 25-30% down.

The vetting of a contractor and having a 203k consultant involved is a small price to pay for getting 110% ARV LTV potential for someone with little experience.




@Matthew Porcaro

I can certainly understand your point of view and advocation for 203(k) loans, however...

In my opinion, and feel free to correct me again, a 203(k) loan is not ideal when utilizing the BRRRR method for the following reasons...

- It's against FHA rules to use a 203K loan for an investment property, unless it's a 2-4 unit multi family and you will live on site.

- 203(k) Loans are for Owner-Occupants

- You can't use a 203(k) loan, legally, if you're planning to rehab/rent(not live in) the property.

- The Cash Out Refi Seasoning Period is 12 Months. The goal of BRRRR is to Cash Out your Cash In the deal ASAP/less than 12mo

- A 203(k) loan is not a scalable loan product. Last time I checked, you can only have 1 at a time.

Personally, I'm not a huge fan of HMLs, but they are a viable loan product for the BRRRR method

Hard Money Lender's don't "Require" anything. They make their own rules and can/do make exceptions.

They are Private Lenders and don't have to abide by the same "Rules" as Traditional Lenders offering Federally Insured Loans.

Just curious, do you charge Beginner Investors you find on BP for your consulting services (The 203k Way)? 

I’m responding to the original posters question who mentioned that they’re open to using 
it as a funding option and wanted more information on it. 

when I see information that’s posted out there about it that’s inaccurate, I chime in. 

you can check my account and my previous posts and see that I myself struggled to find the right information about it when I first started into investing. 

the 203k is great for house hacking, which in and of itself is an investment strategy. 

you can use the BRRRR strategy with it as well because you can build equity into the property and use that equity to go buy additional real estate.

yes, the caveat is owner occupancy for a year. And if you follow the guidelines, as I mentioned above, you can go and refinance and move and do it again. 

Fannie Mae has also changed their guidelines with buying multifamily homes with only 5% down if you occupy the property. And you can have up to 11 of those loans under your name. 

so the process is repeatable as long as you follow the guidelines. 

im not saying its the best option, but im saying its a viable option, and what annoys me most is when I see so much misinformation posted about it anywhere. 

the reason I created my YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram communities around the topics was because I saw how many times people were posting here asking questions about the 203k and were getting the wrong answers or mislead constantly by people with no deep & hands on experience with the program. 

I’ve made thousands of hours of videos and posts  on the subject, all on YouTube Instagram and FB

My only goal is to stop the misinformation and make people aware that it exists and it’s indeed a viable and quite honestly only option that worked for me after years of trying to break into real estate investing in a HCOL in NY. 

Post: NEWBIE FIRST DEAL-FLIP What is your opinion on these funding strategies? Next steps?

Matthew Porcaro
Lender
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 427
  • Votes 319
Quote from @Tony Pellettieri:
Quote from @Kaitlyn Aragon:
Quote from @Matthew Porcaro:
Quote from @Kaitlyn Aragon:
Quote from @Nicholas L.:

@Kaitlyn Aragon

i think i posted in your other thread, but did you rule out house hacking, or a live in flip?  i can't remember.

a big flip is just a very risky way to get started... a house hack or a live in flip are lower risk (not no risk, but lower risk.)

miscellaneous reactions

-you don't buy a flip with a DSCR loan - if you converted it to a BRRRR, you would refi into a DSCR loan.  you'd use the DSCR loan to pay off the hard money loan.

-"if you find the deal the money will find you" - once you're an experienced operator, not on your first.  so yep, don't trust that.  

-no one is going to save you if you buy a bad deal.  you'll have to pay back whatever loan you take out.  say you think you can sell for 300K or whatever the case is, but comps are at 250K when you're done.  that hard money loan is still due.  period.  they couldn't care less that you misread the comps - you'll have to cover whatever the difference is with your own cash.

-the best flips generally are not on market. so if you're looking at on-market deals with an agent... you're probably wasting your time. once a while something will come along and go on the MLS but in general distressed properties are sold off market.

-it's not just about losing money, it's about time and effort.  say you budget for a 3 month rehab and it takes 7 and you break even after you sell.  great, you haven't lost money... but you wasted 7 months.

hope this helps

I did rule out house hacking unless it would be a duplex - which has been proven to be difficult to find here in Charlotte. I did not rule out living in a flip - I am actually looking more into a 203K loan. I don't necessarily love the idea of being tied down to a house for a year but if it is what gets me started then i'm willing. Thanks for that info about the DSCR loan - that makes much more sense. Do you have any suggestions to find more off market properties? I have been put on some wholesalers lists but you have to act very fast and without much time to evaluate the property. 





 I know a year may seem like a long time, but remember real estate investing is a long game. When I got my first duplex using a 203k, especially it being a fixer upper, the renovation alone took almost 8 months to complete. I wasn't in the property very long until I had the ability to refinance and continue on my journey. 

Dollar for dollar its the best way to start and your money will go a lot longer in the long term. 

As far as finding properties off market, I wouldn't focus too much on wholesalsers if you're looking to do a 203k or homestyle reno loan. I'd focus on agent outreach. Go to zillow and sort by lowest prices in your market. Call every single listing agent (include pending sales) and let them know your criteria. Keep them on a list and follow up with them. If there are agents that are receptive, invite them to coffee or a lunch and build those relationships. 

My flipping business was entirely built on agent relationships. At the end of the day they're the ones that get the lowest hanging fruit. 

Other off-market strategies work, but you have to be willing to put the time, money, and effort into sticking with it long enough to see results. 


Hey Matthew, Thanks for your response! I am quickly learning how much of a "long game" REI really is. I have been gaining momentum for three years and I often think if I had just pulled the trigger years ago I would be in a much better position. BUT looking forward. I am glad your 203K investment worked out - gives me hope for mine!

I am currently working with 2 agents and I am looking to reach out to more once my funding is locked in. Thanks for the advise on how to go about that. Relationships have gotten me more movement than any mentorship I've been in so I agree!

203K Loans can be helpful but can take much away from the bottom line as there are many fees, similar to those of a hard money loan, that are incorporated into the loan on the back end for inspections, draws, follow up, etc, often times +/- $10k-$15k, depending on the size of the loan/rehab budget. Just something to be aware of.

Personally, I'd recommend a HM Rehab Loan, over a 203k loan, as the draw fees are usually only around $100 each, and you can send pictures over to the HML to gain access to your draws. As you'll find, traditional financing, especially FHA, can be a real pain in the butt. So many hoops to jump through, and more so for the less savvy real estate investor.

No idea where you're getting $10-15K in "fees" on a 203k. The HUD consultant would be a maximum of about $1500 or so, and that includes the draws and an inspection on the property, and a full creation of a scope of work. A lender is going to charge anywhere between 2-3% in origination points, and that's no different than any other mortgage. Not to mention, all of these fees are wrapable into the loan.

Also, recommending a HML for someone that's new, saying that it's somehow easier than working with an FHA 203k doesn't make much sense. HML's require their borrowers to have experience in construction or flipping, where a 203k does not. The reason for the few extra pieces of paperwork is to help people with no experience have a more controlled process. I worked in large construction in NYC for over 10 years. Everything required on a 203k is how every construction project should be handled. Having a clear scope of work, a vetted, licensed and insured contractor, and someone to objectively inspect the work is not a "pain", its how every project should be handled.

But the biggest most glaring difference, is you only need 3.5% down on an FHA 203k. On a HML with someone with little experience, you're looking at 25-30% down.

The vetting of a contractor and having a 203k consultant involved is a small price to pay for getting 110% ARV LTV potential for someone with little experience.




Post: NYC area: looking for an agent and loan officers specialized in FHA 203K loan

Matthew Porcaro
Lender
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 427
  • Votes 319
Quote from @Yang Zhou:
Quote from @Tracey Watler:

Love this post tons of information.... I have 2-3 banks that offer 203k loans the scrutiny of the self sufficiency test maybe hard but not impossible. You can also consider a conventional rehab now that 2-4 units only requires min of 5% owner-occupied. feel free to reach out I would love to help. 


Thank you! Thats great info Tracey. I did not know conventional loan has the rehab option as well for multi-unit with 5% down.  I will certainly look into this more. Have you worked with a client recently that did a conventional reahb loan ? what are the pros/cons of it compared to fha 203k? 


Im in long island area, but have helped several people do 203k's in NYC. The new Fannie Mae 5% down HomeStyle product on owner occupied multifamily is very similar to the 203k. 

The pros and cons are limited. Pro's of it are Fannie Mae is a bit more flexible with guidelines, and looser on renovation requirements. It also technically doesnt require a hud consultant, which some say is a positive thing, but I'm not convinced. Because with the right consultant they can provide a ton of value such as creating your scope of work and validating the contractor bids for feasibility. You also get lower Mortgage Insurance on the fannie mae version, as well as no up front mortgage insurance payment (1.75% of the total loan amount due at closing) then 0.55% year over year. 

Cons are the conventional product is a lot less forgiving on credit score and LTV. Your credit should be in the 700's to get the best rates and terms. Also, depending on the number of units, they may require you to get a property management company if you have no landlording experience. That came up in the guidelines but I'm not sure how much lenders are enforcing it.

I know several lenders that do these in NYC and am happy to intro you if you need. 

Post: Finding off market properties

Matthew Porcaro
Lender
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 427
  • Votes 319

There are so many different strategies to finding off market deals. I'll tell you how I found my own primary residence in a very competitive market as well. 

My wife and I drove the entire neighborhood and took down every address of a property that we saw ourselves purchasing. We were looking for fixer uppers in a very specific area of Long Island NY, and were only looking for Capes, Colonials, and ranches. 

The more specific your criteria the better, because it makes the next step a lot more efficient. 

We then mailed to all of the property owners using Ballpoint Marketing mailers. They're about 1.80 a piece of mail, but they're handwritten and sent on greeting card style stationary. 

I mentioned that me and my wife were outgrowing our apartment and looking to move into the area. The response rate was great, and we ended up finding an older lady who was moving to a senior living facility and wanted to sell the house as-is with no contingencies. We used a fannie mae homestyle loan to take it as-is and renovate it using the banks money. 

The Facebook/Craigslist strategy works too. 

Post: NEWBIE FIRST DEAL-FLIP What is your opinion on these funding strategies? Next steps?

Matthew Porcaro
Lender
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 427
  • Votes 319
Quote from @Kaitlyn Aragon:
Quote from @Nicholas L.:

@Kaitlyn Aragon

i think i posted in your other thread, but did you rule out house hacking, or a live in flip?  i can't remember.

a big flip is just a very risky way to get started... a house hack or a live in flip are lower risk (not no risk, but lower risk.)

miscellaneous reactions

-you don't buy a flip with a DSCR loan - if you converted it to a BRRRR, you would refi into a DSCR loan.  you'd use the DSCR loan to pay off the hard money loan.

-"if you find the deal the money will find you" - once you're an experienced operator, not on your first.  so yep, don't trust that.  

-no one is going to save you if you buy a bad deal.  you'll have to pay back whatever loan you take out.  say you think you can sell for 300K or whatever the case is, but comps are at 250K when you're done.  that hard money loan is still due.  period.  they couldn't care less that you misread the comps - you'll have to cover whatever the difference is with your own cash.

-the best flips generally are not on market. so if you're looking at on-market deals with an agent... you're probably wasting your time. once a while something will come along and go on the MLS but in general distressed properties are sold off market.

-it's not just about losing money, it's about time and effort.  say you budget for a 3 month rehab and it takes 7 and you break even after you sell.  great, you haven't lost money... but you wasted 7 months.

hope this helps

I did rule out house hacking unless it would be a duplex - which has been proven to be difficult to find here in Charlotte. I did not rule out living in a flip - I am actually looking more into a 203K loan. I don't necessarily love the idea of being tied down to a house for a year but if it is what gets me started then i'm willing. Thanks for that info about the DSCR loan - that makes much more sense. Do you have any suggestions to find more off market properties? I have been put on some wholesalers lists but you have to act very fast and without much time to evaluate the property. 





 I know a year may seem like a long time, but remember real estate investing is a long game. When I got my first duplex using a 203k, especially it being a fixer upper, the renovation alone took almost 8 months to complete. I wasn't in the property very long until I had the ability to refinance and continue on my journey. 

Dollar for dollar its the best way to start and your money will go a lot longer in the long term. 

As far as finding properties off market, I wouldn't focus too much on wholesalsers if you're looking to do a 203k or homestyle reno loan. I'd focus on agent outreach. Go to zillow and sort by lowest prices in your market. Call every single listing agent (include pending sales) and let them know your criteria. Keep them on a list and follow up with them. If there are agents that are receptive, invite them to coffee or a lunch and build those relationships. 

My flipping business was entirely built on agent relationships. At the end of the day they're the ones that get the lowest hanging fruit. 

Other off-market strategies work, but you have to be willing to put the time, money, and effort into sticking with it long enough to see results. 

Post: 203k lenders for Philadelphia area

Matthew Porcaro
Lender
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 427
  • Votes 319
Quote from @Giang Nguyen:

@Jose Perez Sorry for the confusion. The fee of the 203k program is high. I checked in with Homebridge, Anniemac, and Allied Mortgage Group for a 203k loan. Didn't even get prequalified with Anniemac for 203k because they required a letter from me saying that I'd sell my primary residence. The program fee of 203k was comparable between both Homebridge and Allied Mortgage group (~13k for a 115k loan, and my monthly payment would be >$900 including tax/insurance because of the higher interest rate for a 203k loan and the private mortgage insurance that would never go away unless you refinance). I think for a 203k loan, the more important thing is the loan officer because it's just such a complicated process. Fee-wise, I think it's pretty standard across. Interest rates may vary but not significantly. 

After I decided to not go with a 203k, someone else from AnnieMac then contacted me about a cash-out refinance on my primary residence and I ended up going with them because they had one of the lower rate/closing costs and my loan officer was super responsive. So I'm using the cash out from my primary residence to buy/rehab the new property. 

You're looking around for a 203k or you're checking homebridge for some other loan?


203k Fees are not inherently high. Some lenders put overlay fees on them because they don't specialize in them and see it as a headache. There are lenders out there that have no overlays on their 203ks, they're the lenders that specialize in renovation lending. You need to shop the origination points. I've seen some go as high as 5-6% which is egregious.

Every branch is different, but look into Cross Country, Guild, Cardinal, & NJ Lenders


Post: fixer upper 203k

Matthew Porcaro
Lender
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 427
  • Votes 319
Quote from @Jaron Walling:

@Matthew Porcaro Approved as in.... contractors willing to work with a 203k lender. None of the contractors we hire are willing to go through that process. They work quick and want paid asap. 


Ok well, that was misleading. There's no contractor list. Any contractor that is licensed, insured, and experienced can do a renovation loan. I've worked with countless contractors that have no problem doing this process. It's really not much different than hard money draws. If a contractor has done insurance work, they can do 203k loans. 

Post: fixer upper 203k

Matthew Porcaro
Lender
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 427
  • Votes 319
Quote from @Jaron Walling:

But... you won't be picking the contractors. The lender gets to pick them from an "approved" consultant list. 


 This isn't true. Where did you hear this from? 

Post: Need starting out advice (South Florida Multifam FHA 203k)

Matthew Porcaro
Lender
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 427
  • Votes 319

@Austin Martinez

Thanks for the shoutout, Scott!

Hey Austin! I love your idea because it’s exactly how i got started with investing.

I’ve helped hundreds of people replicate the process. the 203k loan is insanely powerful when leveraged correctly.

The fact is, many people don’t have the patience or the resources to pursue it effectively.

I work pretty hard to help clear the air for people looking to take advantage.

To answer your other questions.

2. The best way to find a 203k loan is by working with lenders of brokerages that specialize in these types of renovation loans.

There’s plenty of these guys and gals out there. You just need to look for their circles.

One easy one is google the 203k endorsement summary. Go to the HUD page and scroll down to the bottom to the most recent month and year.

It’ll spit out a report that tells you which companies have done 203k’s in your market.

Call them up and ask them who heads up their reno loan dept.

That way you have lenders that understand the process and can make it easier for you.

3. You can absolutely use a 203k for offmarket deals. I’m in the process of doing another one myself found using off-market leads.

As long as you find a seller that isn’t looking to close on an exact date, you can still purchase as-is, beat up properties.

Hope this all helps my man!

Matt

Post: Your experience using FHA 203K loan

Matthew Porcaro
Lender
Pro Member
Posted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Long Island, NY
  • Posts 427
  • Votes 319

@Philip Roedig

Definitely don’t use someone that hasn’t done it before lol. That’s the most classic mistake people make. Myself included.

There’s plenty of experienced 203k lenders on Long Island that you can use instead.

You can look up Intercontinental Capital Group, Mortgage Possible, Caliber Home Loans to name a few that I know of off hand.