Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Matt Bob

Matt Bob has started 1 posts and replied 13 times.

Quote from @Alex Pelletier:
Quote from @Matt Bob:
Quote from @Nicole Heasley Beitenman:
Quote from @Matt Bob:
Quote from @Nicole Heasley Beitenman:

I would be hesitant to pay you for one tax service and a CPA for another. It would be cleaner for me to pay one person to do it all if I could find that. But I might be in the minority; I'm curious to hear what others have to say.

I can clearly hear prospdcts saying this. Thanks for the feedback! I guess to be a little clearer, I would be creating monthly FS's that the cpa would just punch into their software. I would easily be able to provide all of the support for how I created the numbers as well. 

The thing is with rentals, owners do not track things well, so as tax preparers we literally just go with whatever we're given. If it looks similar to last year, then it passes our sniff test. That catches things like insurance or mortgage interest, but not the 1-time purchases. I actually had a client that randomly brought in a $5k insulation invoice because I asked about a refund (completely different things). 

If I created FS's and reconciled like the large investors do, this would be virtually impossible, and a much better product than the cpa firms can create. 

I'm not sure how I would market this understanding without one-on-one meetings that I would need to quit my job to have... all in the hope people would see the benefit of paying for a service versus pulling their hair out at year end tax time.

I understand what you want to do and see the value, but if there's anyone out there will to both organize financials AND complete the tax return, the client is more likely to go with them. If they aren't organizing their financials after a year or two of doing this, they likely don't care about any extra fees from their CPA for the time spent organizing financials. 

Thanks for the feedback. I watched a couple videos on AZIBO as mentioned above and it appears to be a dumbed down but cluttered up version of QB's in some ways. I think most investors want something easier to use, BUT I also noticed they couldn't break 3k views on Youtube, further emphasizing a lack on investor interest. 

I suspect I am stuck in tax preparation services for a while longer. 

Hey Cliff,

Thanks for taking a look at some of the Azibo videos on accounting (this is a brand new set of features we have yet to start advertising!). Azibo is completely free to test, and someone from our team is willing to give you a full demo or help with onboarding if you want to check us out. 

We're confident that Azibo will make it easy to go from setup to tax-ready reports in just a couple of hours-- feel free to shoot me a DM if you have any questions at all

Disclaimer: I'm part of the Azibo team :) 


Hi Alex, it's Matt, but you can me whatever you like... as long as it's not Late to Dinner.

Need an accountant on your team? 😀

Quote from @Cliff Benner:

@Matt Bob from what I am understanding you are wanting to start doing Bookkeeping/Accounting Services for Real Estate Investors? Provide them with financials monthly and help them to hand off finished financials to their Tax Preparer? 

That is what my wife and I do with our Coaching and Bookkeeping Business. We use Wave(free) and QBO depending on the scope of work. QBO allows different categorization to different classes, Wave does not(found this out with growing pains, get what you pay for though) but you can find solutions for them. 

If that is the case, I would find a job in real estate that allows you to do this on the side, for the mean time and grow your network, so you can build it up and find out what works for your demographic, then sell what you do, learn what you need to do better(just found out I need to add a new step to my analysis of potential clients), and offer them a good product. Charge a base rate, get reviews, and experience, then charge more when you grow and are worth more. 

You talk about making the CPA's  or tax preparer's life easier. They won't be the ones paying you, I think you need to shift focus to helping the clients and what you can do to better their lives. 

What I do for my bookkeeping clients; I prepare your financials monthly to track expenses and help you to read the story of your business month to month, I prepare financials so you can easily have 1099s prepared in January and prepare financials to send to your Tax accountant and organize your details so a you don't need to give them a shoe box or any statements. It is ready to be entered and you save money on not paying that Accountant's hourly rate to organize paper for you. I will let you know if expense are missing or higher then normal, help you to make sure you have all your business expense accounted for, and I create reports to track all Balance Sheet items so that way we are ready for an Audit, if that happens. I have a Master's degree in Accounting and worked in Public accounting doing bookkeeping/financials for 7 years and taxes for 6 years.


This shows the benefits to them, they have someone who knows what they do and can talk about it to make sure transactions are accounted for, peace of mind I am qualified, peace of mind that an Audit will not be as scary with me compared to without me, financials will be proper and they have someone to help them translate this, and being prepared for tax season means they will save money. Less stress and saving money per year will get people's attention.

I think you are on the right track and have a good idea, you identified a problem and have started creating a solution, you just need to refine it and implement it. YOU GOT THIS! 

Love this Cliff, and thanks for the time you spent responding!!! 

Would it be possible to reach out directly if I decide to do this and ask more specific questions?

Either way, thanks again!
Quote from @Jay Thomas:

It's an interesting question. While I'm hesitant to pay one person for two different tax services, others may prefer the convenience of dealing with just one professional. Real estate investments can be particularly complicated in terms of tax planning, so it might make sense to hire a CPA and a tax preparer if you're looking at multiple real estate investments. On the

It's other hand, if you have true that having a one person straightforward to do it all situation can that be doesn a't great involve idea, especially when considering taxes real related to Real Estate investments estate. Real Estate or tax laws complex are investments complex, and then require paying expertise from someone both to an do accountant it and all a could tax save prepare timer. and As money such., It it really may comes make sense down to for Real individual needs Estate and investors preferences to; what consider works paying for for one one service person in may order not to work avoid for confusion another or mistakes. that It could's be costly always down worth the exploring line. your Of course options, before this is making just any my decisions opinion.; What I do'm other curious people think to? Do hear they what prefer others having have separate to professionals say as for well. different tax services, or do they prefer having one professional handle it all? Additionally, what other considerations should Real Estate investors take into account when choosing who manage to their taxes? I'm eager to hear the perspectives of others!

Thabks for joining in and sharing your thoughts.
Quote from @Nicole Heasley Beitenman:
Quote from @Matt Bob:
Quote from @Nicole Heasley Beitenman:

I would be hesitant to pay you for one tax service and a CPA for another. It would be cleaner for me to pay one person to do it all if I could find that. But I might be in the minority; I'm curious to hear what others have to say.

I can clearly hear prospdcts saying this. Thanks for the feedback! I guess to be a little clearer, I would be creating monthly FS's that the cpa would just punch into their software. I would easily be able to provide all of the support for how I created the numbers as well. 

The thing is with rentals, owners do not track things well, so as tax preparers we literally just go with whatever we're given. If it looks similar to last year, then it passes our sniff test. That catches things like insurance or mortgage interest, but not the 1-time purchases. I actually had a client that randomly brought in a $5k insulation invoice because I asked about a refund (completely different things). 

If I created FS's and reconciled like the large investors do, this would be virtually impossible, and a much better product than the cpa firms can create. 

I'm not sure how I would market this understanding without one-on-one meetings that I would need to quit my job to have... all in the hope people would see the benefit of paying for a service versus pulling their hair out at year end tax time.

I understand what you want to do and see the value, but if there's anyone out there will to both organize financials AND complete the tax return, the client is more likely to go with them. If they aren't organizing their financials after a year or two of doing this, they likely don't care about any extra fees from their CPA for the time spent organizing financials. 

Thanks for the feedback. I watched a couple videos on AZIBO as mentioned above and it appears to be a dumbed down but cluttered up version of QB's in some ways. I think most investors want something easier to use, BUT I also noticed they couldn't break 3k views on Youtube, further emphasizing a lack on investor interest. 

I suspect I am stuck in tax preparation services for a while longer. 

Quote from @Account Closed:
Quote from @Matt Bob:

I have done tax prep for 7 years and the rentals are always a low value, high input tax return. The client thinks bringing in a wad of receipts is legit and you're stuck categorizing everything in excel while thinking about how much trouble you'll be in for spending too much time on the return (like you wanted to). 

The clients almost never bring everything in, which tells me they don't really know what's happening with their investments. 

I am playing with the idea of starting my own business where I categorize rental properties monthly and POTENTIALLY prep the tax return at year end as well. I could also help prepare Personal FS's. If I didn't do the tax return, then the CPA would just have to 10-key things in in a matter of seconds.

Is there a need for this In the rental business where investors would be willing to pay?


Thanks in advance.


Hi Matt,
Have you looked at Azibo yet?  They seem to have a similar program to what you are considering:
https://www.azibo.com/accounti...

I definitely see a need for better expense tracking, either manual entry or connecting with my bank account to make it easier.  Thanks!
I haven't, but I'll check it out. Thanks for the lead!
Quote from @Simon W.:

Okay, got it.

Well, first thing first, is that it's the owners' fault for commingling personal and business. That's why it is a headache. If they get a professional doing it from the beginning and teaches them, it won't be a headache anymore.

I've been in the real estate accounting for 16+ years and if the PM is managing it, there shouldn't be any other additional expenses besides hiring their own maintenance techs to do the work. It sounds like the people you were auditing/tax prepping were not doing their books the proper way. This is more of a clean up then anything else.

I wish you best of luck to try to do build your own platform.

Yes, usually it is when they hire the maint twchs themselves, they pay them personally rather than the mgmt company. 

Thanks, I appreciate the well wishes!
Quote from @Simon W.:
Quote from @Matt Bob:


Their mgmt reports our local mgmt companies produce are attrocious for tax purposes. They are cash basis mgmt reports without any of the owner's expenses.... so rents, mgmt fees, mgmt repairs. I think you are opening my eyes to the fact our small market is even more old school than I judged it. It sounds like tou take the step of including their personal expenses IN the mgmt reports?

you are correct, at the end of the day, the owners would still need the worksheets reconciled and reclassed.


 90% of the real estate investors books are cash basis. PM company won't have owner's expenses that related to the rental company because there wouldn't really be any because the PM is handling it all. It isn't old school.

If they are self managing, then you will have to do something different which includes your all income and expenses related to the building/business/LLC. But you never include personal expenses in to the financial statements.

I am bit confused with your post. Are you trying to sell a service or you are trying to get a job in the RE world?


I can see how that would be confusing. I have already gone down the road of applying to RE management companies with 300B in assets. They are all remote positions and my credientials aren't enough to overcome the experience my competition brings. 

I am now going down the road of considering a build my own book of business idea.

I know you would think all expenses are captured in the PM company reports but trust me, they never are. Owners still put in money and the tax preparers still need to combine information from all sources. This is why I said they are a headache. Technically, the issue isn't pulling personal expenses out of the business bank account, it is pulling the business expenses out of the personal account. It's a slight difference that makes a big headache.


I have done audited, compiled, reviewed and SARRS 21 reports, in addition to tax. The personal expense thing is an issue to consider.

Quote from @Simon W.:

I personally have clients who have 5-10 rentals and some even just 4. So yes they hire me because I can get the job done in a quick manner and review their financials at the same time. By the time they bring there FS to their CPAs, the CPAs barely have to do any work besides filing.

I also oversee 1500+ units and ton of owners have 1-4 units and they are spending money on CPAs. Our PM software (AppFolio) is already helping them categorize it with the management fees. Again, their CPAs don't need to do much besides punching those financial numbers and computing depreciation expenses.

Not sure how it is complicated in your market. RE accounting is pretty much standard across the US. Federal Taxes are the same, only difference is which State and that's barely any changes to be made.

There are also other people in BP that already created this type of platform and produced these prefilled Scheduled E and it doesn't last because at the end it is better to have a professional do it right from the start.

The platform you are creating or created, are you reviewing the expenses to make sure they are properly recorded? or you just plan to just sell the subscription only?

Well ideally, I would find a role like you have running the books for a RE firm, but there are only two of those in my market and they under pay. The remote positions I apply for have candidates with direct experience, so my tax experience and professional certification aren't getting me seen. 

Their mgmt reports our local mgmt companies produce are attrocious for tax purposes. They are cash basis mgmt reports without any of the owner's expenses.... so rents, mgmt fees, mgmt repairs. I think you are opening my eyes to the fact our small market is even more old school than I judged it. It sounds like tou take the step of including their personal expenses IN the mgmt reports?

you are correct, at the end of the day, the owners would still need the worksheets reconciled and reclassed.

Quote from @Simon W.:

Isn't this basically what bookkeepers and accountants are already doing?

If you created a software, that categorize things, how is it any different than the 100s of platforms such as Stessa, QBO, Sage, Wave, Xero, Freshbook, and many others.

Owner still need someone to classify them to the proper place and reconcile the accounts.


Well you're an accountant, so let me ask you... how many clients do you do bookkeeping for that have 5-10 rentals? In my experience, they are averaging $3k/yr after depreciation with a good portfolio. They aren't spending money on an accountant. In 7 yeaes, I think I've only evwr had two clients that used quickbooks with classes.

It's too complicated for what a RE owner in my market wants to do. Whether they're willing to do something simpler is yet to be seen though.

Quote from @Joe Villeneuve:
Quote from @Matt Bob:
Quote from @Joe Villeneuve:

Excellent idea, but I can see how many would look a this as a redundant cost.  My suggestion would be to design everything in an Excel spreadsheet, call it software, and sell it with instructions on how to fill it out.  Sell it as a subscription model and make multiple incomes per user.

Thanks Joe,

I actually already built that. I gor resistance from two sides. The partners didn't want to send it to clients because they wouldn't use it, and clients... well didn't want to do it thenselves. 

This was before ever reaching the instructional piece of using the spread sheet.

Another barrier to this, is once sold, anyone could just email it around (right)?

No.  You can add invisible timers and/or counters that will disable the software after a certain number of uses of a date.  I usually do the number of uses.
Oohhhh reeaalllllyyyy?????

Where would one sell such a thing. I've never heard of a space for this much less seen a client bring anything in that looks accountant designed.