Morning Jodi,
I tend to agree with the other posters...it seems like your property is potentially under-rented. I'm guessing based on that value that you've got a 2 bedroom, 1 bath detached home. Is that right? For the most part, including the majority of the suburbs, $1,175 seems low to me. Whereabouts is the house?
1st step for me would be to check with your property managers and see when was the last time they did a rent comparison? Double check that with your own research. After that, take into account the new LL/Tenant laws in Oregon to see how long it'll take to get rents up to market, or if it's even worth it. Once you've got that info you can plug it in to your spreadsheets and see what happens to your cashflow from there...maybe that then becomes worth it to keep.
At the same time, I'd take a look around-what can you get for the equity in your own backyard? Do you live in another expensive market like Portland, or do you have access to better cash-flow at home? I wouldn't want to trade the house without knowing the pros and cons of where you're putting the money!
Hope that helps give you an idea of next steps...
Mathew