Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Mary Winter

Mary Winter has started 5 posts and replied 28 times.

Post: Bathtub Repair Question

Mary WinterPosted
  • Posts 28
  • Votes 2
Quote from @JD Martin:
Quote from @Mary Winter:

Hello BP community! I have another bathtub question. Here is a picture of the tub. This a one piece fiberglass bathtub. There is a small hole in the bottom of the bathtub (dark spot in the picture). This is causing water leaks. The repair guy is suggesting to replace the flooring of the bathtub because patches would crack in a week or two. Can this be done for a one piece bathtub? 

Any advice you can provide would be greatly appreciated! 


 Depends on the quality of the repair and how well the tub is supported. Generally plastic and fiberglass, to fix right especially on the floor, you're better off just replacing the tub.


 This is on the second floor, which is why they are suggesting to replace the flooring. 

Replacing the tub was considered, but it is too costly. I would need to re-do the entire bathroom. The builder put in the bathtub first before enclosing the bathroom walls. 

Post: Bathtub Repair Question

Mary WinterPosted
  • Posts 28
  • Votes 2

Hello BP community! I have another bathtub question. Here is a picture of the tub. This a one piece fiberglass bathtub. There is a small hole in the bottom of the bathtub (dark spot in the picture). This is causing water leaks. The repair guy is suggesting to replace the flooring of the bathtub because patches would crack in a week or two. Can this be done for a one piece bathtub? 

Any advice you can provide would be greatly appreciated! 

Quote from @Armin Shivazad:

Jason, thank you for the reply. I believe I understand your explanation for the 1065 and the adjusted cost basis so thank you for that. 

My other question is can you please explain how to remove the building and depreciation reported under the individual tax return when transferring the property to be recorded under the partnership return? The reason for my question is how to deal with the depreciation that I took already under my individual 1040? Does that have to somehow be removed?


Again, thanks for the explanation and your time.


You don't have to remove/amend your 2022 return because the property was under your name in 2022. You didn't transfer the property to your LLC until 2023.

Quote from @Corby Goade:

Why are you involved in this at all? Your PM should have proactivlely addressed all of this without creating any undue stress for you. 

Any PM worth their salt would have already served notice and had the ball rolling on eviction and just looped you in on the situation. 

To directly answer your question- if your PM hasn't already taken action, fire them, hire an attorney to start the eviction process and start interviewing new property managers. 

Sorry you are dealing with this. 

Thank you Corby! No I don't want to be involved in this at all. A lot of stress.
The tenant told my PM that these people will leave after three weeks. My PM sent her emails and told her that these people need to leave after that time. I told him to serve an official notice of lease violation to the tenant. If she fails to notify me when she has guests staying over 72 hrs again, she will be evicted. 
My PM said he has to believe her that these people are her families because he does not have solid proof that she is subletting the property. Words from neighbors are not enough. However, I know she does not live there because her car is not in the driveway any time of the day.  
How can I catch these people? 
Quote from @Bob Stevens:
Quote from @Mary Winter:

Hello BP community, I am really anxious about the current situation in my rental in FL.  

I have a 3 bedroom rental that is managed by my PM. End of February, one tenant moved into the property. She has good credit scores, job, money in the bank, etc. She is the only person on the lease. Our neighbors told us that there are at least 3 adults ( one young couple, one old man) and 2 very young kids living in our property. They are there since the beginning of the lease. However, it does not look like the tenant on the lease is living in the property. When our PM confronted her, she said they are her family visiting her. They will leave in three weeks. She also did not notify us ahead of time. Our neighbors also noticed that the kids like to lean on the second floor windows, and it looks like the windows are open. So the kids are leaning on the screens, which is a HUGE SAFETY HAZARD! I also don't believe these people are her families visiting her because she does not live in the property. 

I want them out. I am so anxious that the kids can fall out of the window. My PM said if the kids fell, I would not be responsible for it because my windows are locked when I rented out the property. However, I don't want the stress or any accidents. I don't want to take any chance. My PM is telling me that I can't remove these people because the tenant did not break the lease, even though she is having guests that stay over 72 hrs without any notifying us. 

I am so anxious about this situation. Any advice you can provide would be greatly appreciated! 

 You are worrying about nothing. Why do you care they have a visitor? What they're doing there has nothing to do with you. 


I don't know what kind of people living in my property. Are they criminals? Are they selling drugs? They are not on the lease. I don't know who they are.

Also, I am worried the kids will fall. I don't want this to happen in my property. I don't want to take a chance and get sued. 

The tenant is not honest. These people are not her families. She is subletting the property. Supposed to be one person on the lease, now there are at least five. More wear and tear to my property too. If they damage anything, I am afraid the security deposit is not enough to cover. My PM only required one month. 

Quote from @Melanie P.:

If she is not living there but others are she has sublet the premises. What does your lease say about subletting?

Your PM can send her a notice of default with whatever cure period is required in your state.


 My lease does not allow sublet. However, she claims these people are her family. My PM said I need to have solid proof of the sublease to start the eviction process. How can I catch them? I have been told that words from neighbors are not enough. 

Also found out that there is no car parked in the driveway any time of the day. The tenant's car is on the lease. Is that sufficient to say she does not live in the property and she is subletting the property to other people? 

Quote from @Account Closed:
Quote from @Mary Winter:

Hello BP community, I am really anxious about the current situation in my rental in FL.  

I have a 3 bedroom rental that is managed by my PM. End of February, one tenant moved into the property. She has good credit scores, job, money in the bank, etc. She is the only person on the lease. Our neighbors told us that there are at least 3 adults ( one young couple, one old man) and 2 very young kids living in our property. They are there since the beginning of the lease. However, it does not look like the tenant on the lease is living in the property. When our PM confronted her, she said they are her family visiting her. They will leave in three weeks. She also did not notify us ahead of time. Our neighbors also noticed that the kids like to lean on the second floor windows, and it looks like the windows are open. So the kids are leaning on the screens, which is a HUGE SAFETY HAZARD! I also don't believe these people are her families visiting her because she does not live in the property. 

I want them out. I am so anxious that the kids can fall out of the window. My PM said if the kids fell, I would not be responsible for it because my windows are locked when I rented out the property. However, I don't want the stress or any accidents. I don't want to take any chance. My PM is telling me that I can't remove these people because the tenant did not break the lease, even though she is having guests that stay over 72 hrs without any notifying us. 

I am so anxious about this situation. Any advice you can provide would be greatly appreciated! 

Hello Mary, thank you for being willing to share your concerns in the BP community. First and foremost, as a landlord, you have the right and obligation to ensure that your property is properly managed and maintained, including making sure tenants comply with the lease agreement and relevant laws and regulations

Start by communicating with your PM, emphasizing your worries about the safety of children. You can point out that even if tenants haven't violated any terms of the contract, as a landlord, it's your responsibility to ensure the safety of the house which includes both tenants and their guests

If PM doesn’t provide an appropriate solution then you will have no choice but to seek legal assistance. Consult a lawyer to understand your rights and obligations

Honestly speaking, such issues are indeed very tricky! 

Thank you for your time replying to my post! I had a serious conversation with my PM, but he said if anything happens to the kids, it would not be my responsibility. Still, not willing to take a chance. The law does not protect landlords these days.  

Quote from @Account Closed:

Sounds like you're dealing with a real headache! Honestly, your PM's response seems kinda iffy. If those folks aren't on the lease and they're staying way longer than they should without giving you a heads-up, that's definitely a red flag. Plus, the safety issue with the kids leaning on those windows? Not cool at all. Maybe it's time to have a serious chat with your PM about your concerns and see if there's a way to address this situation before it gets any worse.

Sean, I agree with you 100%. I had a serious chat with the PM and expressed about my concerns. The PM said not to worry about it because it is not my responsibility, even if the kids fall out of the window. He said it's common for people with kids. I am also suspecting if these people are just leaving the kids at home alone. 

Quote from @Michael Moy:

What does the lease say about guest?  If the lease says 72 hours then they are in violation and in most states you are required to give the tenants notice and x amount of time to correct the situation prior to eviction.  If your PM doesn't want to follow the lease and your wishes, might be time to look for a new PM.  If your lease does not address guest stay lengths and it is legal to do so in your state might want to look for a new PM. In the mean time, I would contact a local real estate lawyer and see what can be done.  Pay a small fee for advice and use it as leverage to get your PM to do what they should be doing in the first place.  If they still refuse, talk to the lawyer about what legal actions you have against your property manager for not following through with their duties.  


The lease requires the tenant to provide a notice if she is going to have guests who stay over 72 hours. My PM just sent an email to her and called it a written evidence. I asked him to issue an official notice of lease violation stating that if she is having more guests staying over 72 hrs without notifying the landlord, we will start the eviction process. My PM said that I have to trust the tenant's words and believe these people are her families. 

Thank you for your suggestion about seeking legal advice! 

Hello BP community, I am really anxious about the current situation in my rental in FL.  

I have a 3 bedroom rental that is managed by my PM. End of February, one tenant moved into the property. She has good credit scores, job, money in the bank, etc. She is the only person on the lease. Our neighbors told us that there are at least 3 adults ( one young couple, one old man) and 2 very young kids living in our property. They are there since the beginning of the lease. However, it does not look like the tenant on the lease is living in the property. When our PM confronted her, she said they are her family visiting her. They will leave in three weeks. She also did not notify us ahead of time. Our neighbors also noticed that the kids like to lean on the second floor windows, and it looks like the windows are open. So the kids are leaning on the screens, which is a HUGE SAFETY HAZARD! I also don't believe these people are her families visiting her because she does not live in the property. 

I want them out. I am so anxious that the kids can fall out of the window. My PM said if the kids fell, I would not be responsible for it because my windows are locked when I rented out the property. However, I don't want the stress or any accidents. I don't want to take any chance. My PM is telling me that I can't remove these people because the tenant did not break the lease, even though she is having guests that stay over 72 hrs without any notifying us. 

I am so anxious about this situation. Any advice you can provide would be greatly appreciated!