Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Maryann Fialdini

Maryann Fialdini has started 5 posts and replied 13 times.

Quote from @Chris Seveney:

@Maryann Fialdini

Definitely get an attorney as you want to avoid her claiming she was induced to sign and it was a predatory situation

In the future never give money, pay for anything or take a deed without going through proper people

Yes it’s Monday morning quarterback but it is sound business practice.

The only way this will get resolved now is through a lawsuit or cash for keys

What is she trying to claim btw ?


I had a title company that advised me every step of the way.  They sent a notary and she signed in front of them, and I gave the title the money and they paid the taxes. She is claiming that "she changed her mind."

Quote from @Chris Seveney:

@Maryann Fialdini

Get an attorney and File for eviction assuming she got the proceeds from the sale of the property from the title company.

She did not get the proceeds because she did not show up for the closing.

Unique situation - need advice.  Seller was facing imminent foreclosure due to unpaid property taxes.  She signed a purchase contract for $75K with closing within 30 days.  Title company started title search and while waiting for results (we knew there were multiple liens that would be paid from proceeds at closing), I paid off property taxes so foreclosure was stopped after seller signed the warranty deed over to me in front of a notary. Once title company had finalized title search, seller decided not to follow thru with the closing.  Title company stated if she refuses to close, I can sue her under the contract for specific performance of the contract and or can just record the deed and take ownership of the property. I opted to record the deed.  Not sure what I should do now to get her out of the property - this is in Florida.

Quote from @Peter Walther:
Quote from @Maryann Fialdini:

Purchased a condo and received an estoppel from HOA - had multiple special assessments identified plus seller's HOA unpaid dues listed and all were paid from proceeds at closing. One month later, lawyer for HOA wrote me a letter saying they made a mistake in computing the special assessments and $62K more is owed. I filed a claim with WFG title insurer and they just denied me saying: "Title insurance is not a casualty insurance that covers every possible loss, nor is it a guarantee of any facts regarding title to real property. Title insurance does not represent the status of title to real property, and an insured cannot rely on the title policy to represent the title. An insurer owes no duty to investigate the condition of the title and makes no representation as to the condition of the title inissuing a title insurance policy.

EXCEPTIONS FROM COVERAGE
This policy does not insure against loss or damage, and the Company will not pay costs, attorneys' fees, or expenses resulting from the terms and conditions of any lease or easement identified in Schedule A and the following matters:

4. Terms, covenants, conditions, easements, restrictions, reservations and other provisions, including provisions which provide for a private charge or assessment and also provide for an option to purchase, a right of first refusal, or the prior approval of a future purchaser or occupant, according to that specific Declaration of Condominium"

But

There is also ALTA 4.1 CONDOMINIUM--CURRENT ASSESSMENTS ENDORSEMENT which states: The Company insures against loss o rdamage sustained by the Insured by reason of: Any charges or assessments provided for in the State condominium statutes and condominium documents due and unpaid at the Date of Policy.

Looking for advise on next steps.


I'm a little confused by your post.  You wrote that you bought a condo but that you're dealing with a homeowner's association rather than a condo owner's association.  You later wrote the property is in Florida.  If that's the case, HOAs are governed by F.S. 720; COAs by F.S. 718.  If it is a COA, F.S. 718.116(8)(c) provides:

(c) An association waives the right to collect any moneys owed in excess of the amounts specified in the estoppel certificate from any person who in good faith relies upon the estoppel certificate and from the person’s successors and assigns.

If it's an HOA, F.S. 720.30851(3) provides:

(3) An association waives the right to collect any moneys owed in excess of the amounts specified in the estoppel certificate from any person who in good faith relies upon the estoppel certificate and from the person’s successors and assigns.

Now there are Master Associations that have an HOA, and the MA has condos built inside them with a separate COA, so some condos can have two assessments, one for the HOA and one for the COA. However, in both associations, if they provided incorrect information that you relied on the purchase the unit, I believe the statute should protect you.

As far as the title insurer's denial, title insurance acts retrospectively, that is from the Date of Policy back in time and from the information you provided, as of today your title is as insured and there is no defect or cloud on your title.  If the Association decided for whatever reason the statute did not apply to your situation and filed a Claim of Lien to enforce the shortage you could resubmit the claim to the insurer and see if they provide coverage.  I suspect they'll again deny coverage, this time as a matter arising after the Date of Policy but I think it's worth a try.

The 4.1 endorsement doesn't help because again, right now it appears title is as insured as of the Date of Policy.

As the coverage letter states, a title policy is not a guarantee of title, it's an insurance policy that reimburses the insured for a covered loss and in some cases provides a defense against allegations in a filed lawsuit.  Though if I were handling claim like yours, I would probably call and talk with the Association's attorney and find out why (s)he thinks the statutes don't apply and then call and talk with the insured and explain the coverage decision and answer any questions before writing a confirmatory letter.  I was well aware that most insured don't have the knowledge to push back against an adverse party who may not themselves be aware of the law.

I hope this helps.

@Peter Walther Yes, it is a COA and does not have a Master HOA.  They are citing 718.116(1)(a) as the basis for them being about to collect from me, the new owner, specifically: "as the new owner of the property, you are jointly and severally liable for the amounts owed by the previous owner under Florida Statutes 718.116(1)(a). This statute states that a unit owner, regardless of how the title was acquired, is responsible for all assessments due while they are the owner and is also liable for any unpaid assessments that came due before the transfer of title."

Thanks for pointing out what F.S. 718.116(8)(c) states as that may help.  To date, they have not filed a claim of lien against me but late fees are accruing as I have not paid towards the special assessment.

If anyone knows a good lawyer that could handle this in Florida I'd appreciate the recommendation.

Quote from @Kevin Sobilo:

@Maryann Fialdini, I hate to say it but you need a good real estate lawyer IN YOUR STATE because HOA laws vary somewhat from place to place.

To my mind, I would think about a few ways to attack the issue:

1. You requested a statement from the HOA and paid it in full at closing and have documentation that you are "paid in full" as of that date. I don't care whom you are paying, I would think that alone should mean something.

2. Apparently no lien was filed. If the HOA had a lien on file before you closed that would better substantiate their claim but given that you obtained title insurance that couldn't have been the case.

3. The title insurance may have denied you because at this point, the bill does not affect title. However, if they try to file a lien or take action against your property THEN perhaps the title company could be compelled to compensate you.

4. What kind of deed did you get from the sellers AND ALSO what does your sales contract state?

The type of deed matters because a Quit Claim Deed makes NO guarantees by the seller about issues affecting title while a Special Warranty or General Warranty deed do! So, if you have a Warranty type deed you may be able to take action against the seller to force them to pay!

The sales contract matters because many sales contracts state that the seller is required to disclose to you any notices affecting the property that might include a special assessment, municipal fine, or in this case money owed to the HOA. So, the seller could also be held liable for not disclosing and turning over those notices to you during the sale.

 @Kevin I am in Florida and was issued a Warranty Deed.

Purchased a condo and received an estoppel from HOA - had multiple special assessments identified plus seller's HOA unpaid dues listed and all were paid from proceeds at closing. One month later, lawyer for HOA wrote me a letter saying they made a mistake in computing the special assessments and $62K more is owed. I filed a claim with WFG title insurer and they just denied me saying: "Title insurance is not a casualty insurance that covers every possible loss, nor is it a guarantee of any facts regarding title to real property. Title insurance does not represent the status of title to real property, and an insured cannot rely on the title policy to represent the title. An insurer owes no duty to investigate the condition of the title and makes no representation as to the condition of the title inissuing a title insurance policy.

EXCEPTIONS FROM COVERAGE
This policy does not insure against loss or damage, and the Company will not pay costs, attorneys' fees, or expenses resulting from the terms and conditions of any lease or easement identified in Schedule A and the following matters:

4. Terms, covenants, conditions, easements, restrictions, reservations and other provisions, including provisions which provide for a private charge or assessment and also provide for an option to purchase, a right of first refusal, or the prior approval of a future purchaser or occupant, according to that specific Declaration of Condominium"

But

There is also ALTA 4.1 CONDOMINIUM--CURRENT ASSESSMENTS ENDORSEMENT which states: The Company insures against loss o rdamage sustained by the Insured by reason of: Any charges or assessments provided for in the State condominium statutes and condominium documents due and unpaid at the Date of Policy.

Looking for advise on next steps.

Yes, I did find a great contractor.  Neil Stanford - 616-890-7163

Quote from @Shane Lafleur:

Id suggest looking into Ballpoint Marketing (BallpointMarketing.com). They have all the machines and cool designs for you so you just send them your list and they take care of the rest. I just ordered my first batch from them this past month on a 7 Month Campaign for a targeted market so I will update on the progress, but I'm excited because its handwritten and a cool design rather than just a yellow post card.

Do you have any feedback after 9 months on your 7 month Campaign?  How effective was it?

Post: Contractor recommendation in Ocala, FL

Maryann FialdiniPosted
  • Posts 13
  • Votes 5

@Josue Molinari sounds great! Please forward any contractor recs to me and would love to work together post rehab.