Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Madison Holbrook

Madison Holbrook has started 5 posts and replied 27 times.

Originally posted by @Keyonte Summers:

You have so many questions but ill try my best to package them so my answer isnt too long. I would recommend watching more content or reading more real-estate books to get a more in depth understanding.  For getting Market value you can get a good realtor to pull that information for you. My agent gets mad at my because I do alot of things before hand just to make sure my deals are good but I always have her double check my numbers. 

Detroit is a unique market its block by block and lenders that specialize in our market knows that. I have criteria for neighborhoods I invest in. I dont buy next to vacant houses, abandon, or burnt houses. Its plenty more but I make sure the numbers work long-term. You can do all the leg work of the Cash-out before hand to find a lender that see's you vision and will work with you on that. This is how i built my team I give them goals and plan, than say how can you make this happen for me, what can you bring to the table if im bringing my business. Banks typically send out their own appraisal company BUT if you dont agree with their valuation you can always bring in a independent/third party appraisal .

For multifamily I dont think their hard to appraise but you can run into issues like I have when they are titled as individual parcels but one structure. 

Your cash equity question is too vague to many dependent things like your credit score, DTI ratio, how appraisal , how much your pulling out. Again get a consistent lender that knows your plan and I always have mine run my numbers to verify my success rate at getting my loans.

I answered the appraisal question above twice over and i have multiple properties on the same block so I dont see it as an issue.

@Madison Holbrook

 Thank you for the answer, I know it was a big round about question. 

Do you use HML or banks as your lenders?

Originally posted by @Christopher Hunter:

@Madison Holbrook  Hello Madison.  You have a lot of great questions.

1. I think investors get into the small units to get there feet wet and get familiar with investing.

2.  Investors spread their capital out to get more deals

3. Yes insurance is different based on liability 

4.  Taxes are based on property value 

5.  Yes there is different liability issues.  That is why there are A,B, C, D class properties 

There is no bad place to start.  Here or there.  You will get great information either place.  2-4 units is the small stuff that you can get regular financing on.  Once you hit 5 units it is time for commercial lending and different parameters.  Have fun learning.

 Thank you for the information! 

When owning an apartment complex that doesn't make the individual taxed differently though. Just income and property taxes? Or does it make you a type of business owner?

I have a couple questions specifically for this market. 

From my understanding and please correct me if I am wrong, convention banks are still hesitant to lend on Detroit properties. Most of this in part to having a hard time appraising them. 

Market Value- how do you find out a good market value for an area when it is renters or old owners who have not sold or flipped something? I was looking in a neighborhood on Zillow where not a lot of stuff had moved since 2011. The things that did were 20k to 30k, from the pictures still available were not flipped. Zooming out the next street was foreclosures and the street behind was 60's and up. I want to say it was the Oakman area. It was very block by block price wise with Zillow which for me doesn't paint an accurate picture. 

How the heck do you gauge that? Do you pass up that property because it's to much of a gamble?

After Repair Value- continuing off of above question I guess... If you buy a property cash and finance some of the rehab on a HML, is it difficult to find a bank to refinance that loan? How do you have your property appraised or do they send someone out? How do they appraise

Duplexes/Four-plexes- Are these harder to appraise or do they appraise as easily as SFM?

Cash Equity Loans- Say you do everything with your own cash. Your property is flipped, it's rented out, money in savings, cash flowing. You're ready to buy a new property and keep going. Cash equity loans …. are they hard to get from a bank on this type of property? Who has done one, who did it, what are rates looking like?

Who and How for appraising? How can one gauge for themselves in the Detroit market where the property will range when it is flipped? 

I'm not opposed to buying on the same street or at least approaching current owners to try so the whole street can improve.

Several questions!

I see a lot of posts about investing in duplexes to four-plexes but not bigger than that. 

 I understand that part of this is probably due to commercial financing. If someone were to have cash to buy a complex would there be that hesitancy?

 Are property managers hesitant to take on an apartment versus a four-plex?

 Is insurance on an apartment building different than a four-plex

 Is the owner put into a different category for taxes based off owning a complex versus a four-plex?

Is it because they can be more of a headache, complaints of "upstairs neighbor stomping, dog barking, baby crying!"

Is there a different sort of liability with the different properties?

Taxes?

Not sure if this should have been in the starting out forum or not.

I'm just looking at my options. 

With a lower income I can't expand as much or fast as I'd like while carrying debt, would have to refi. Owning in cash is appealing to me, especially when it doesn't put me into another tax bracket at that point. 

I'd also be able to put it as my llc. Instead of liability being on me, having the potential of being sued. 

I own most of my things. i don't carry a lot of debt. 

Not saying I have a lot but what i have I buy nice and maintain such as my car. I own a plug in hybrid that will be paid off at the end of 2020. 

Being protected by having properties under and llc is my goal for all my properties at least after the first if I do end up buying a multifamily first. 

I'm trying to weigh out my options. Everyone either feels so strongly for one or the other, where as for me I see both sides. 

Originally posted by @Monte Blunk:

Have you thought about Heber, summit park, or bountiful? Much better air quality in Heber and summit park.  Just a thought.  We own multiple MF properties in SLC and one in the park city area so know the markets and area well.  We also live in SLC (moves from Seattle 10 years ago) and you could look at homes with MIL apartments.  This way you could live in the MIL apartment and rent the main house out to cover your mortgage.  This is how we started in Seattle many years ago and it set us up to keep costs down and save money.  There are many houses in the Sugarhouse, Aves, liberty wells area that work really well for that.  Just a thought.  J

Thank you for the input! Yes, I'm keeping my eye on bountiful. MIL can be tricky from what I've heard. If they're not metered separately the bank has a hard time counting it as 2 units for the loan and rental income, unless permits were pulled to make it a multi unit with whatever city official. Do you have input on this?

 I'm contacting numerous for sales that I see. I was also going to be speaking to another lender than just that one but that's what i mean when the approval on my income would be hard to if I couldn't include that income a 350k house is gonna be out of my reach. That's the main issue for me. Even with the right amount for fha saved, if I can't get that rental counted towards income, the loans will be out of reach. 

I could be looking in Taylorsville or WVC but that would just be less than ideal for most of those homes. 

I really love Midvale, Cottonwood, Sandy, SoJo, Herriman, Draper, lehi (some of it is still affordable), Holladay, Millcreek, and parts of Salt Lake that you listed except maybe aves. Sugarhouse and liberty are easier for a single family due to more affordable daycare and better schools. That's a huge thing for me. I love that area. it's my favorite. So much to do that is family friendly, outdoors, not super crowded, clean, low traffic, right by my school. I love it. 

Is there anyone who has purchased but not been a resident of MI? 

Purchased under an llc that can do business in MI or had someone in MI purchase it for them?

Originally posted by @Matthew Fassett:

Even with comments and words people say to us our minds can perceive them differently. I for one second don’t believe someone came up to you and said ummm no your child isn’t part of our religion can’t play sorry. I believe she said something different  and you simply interpreted it as my child can’t play because of this or because of that. Our mind is a very powerful place. Sometimes it can be a powerfully dark place or a powerfully happy place. We need to decide which one we will support the most. 

 Choose to believe what you want. Telling a child at a park she can't play because she is not a part of the word, is in fact excluding her based off of that. 

Happy valley in your happy place, ain't that right ;)

Originally posted by @Matthew Fassett:

Question for all of you who think certain areas are so judgmental. Have you ever stopped and thought. Hmmmm maybe I’m the one that’s being judgmental about these people and they really aren’t being judgmental towards me at all? Maybe this is a story I’m telling myself to make me feel better of my own insecurities? 

 Yes, I can say that some times I've wondered if it's my own perception. 

However, when there are blatant comments and not just innuendos that's how I know the difference. 

Being told my child can't play because she isn't a part of a church ward mind you this was a mother my child is 2, how I'm clearly not a member or active member because I have a child out of wedlock, how I couldn't be hired to a unit because I wouldn't fit in as it was a predominantly married female lds and they were looking for someone who would fit in with current staff, this was after being asked if I had kids oh what does your husband do, oh so you're a single mom.... that's judgement, discrimination, and hate.

Wondering if the group of moms will care if I sit with them at a park? That's insecurity.

I live in an area where I'm encouraged, supported, and value. For tenacity, independence, and intelligent mind. 

There will be people anywhere you go who judge, have bias, or are just crappy people. 

You can always choose how to take things. I take them with a grain of salt, find the humor or good in it, or I ignore it. 

I choose to live in a forward, progressive, activist community. 

Yes it is a college down but more so for BYU, which is a religious restricted college.

Utah is a great place. Gorgeous! Outdoor enthusiasts dream. I love it here in salt lake county or more north. I try to stay out of utah county, anything south of lehi.

There is a huge amount of judgement, even more so given that I'm a single mom. It really makes a pariah out of me. I'm truly not dramatizing it. Suicide is extremely high here due to religious impact. 

Schools are definitely a huge thing, especially needing somewhere good with my daughters medical needs. Washington schools have nurses. Utahs do not at least not a majority of them.