@Michael Baum
Thanks for the input!
My place will be the biggest within a 45 minute drive by a rather significant margin.
There really isn’t an option for 3 different scenarios, it is only is 2. The 2nd portion of the house does not have a full kitchen, it also does not have access to the second level screened in porch and there is no way to split the exterior without putting up a wall through the large deck which I’m not willing to do. The setup for the second portion of the house plays well for more people sleeping and hedging out, but not necessarily a stand alone unit. If I did two separate units privacy would be minimal and I would need a different set of licensing agreements since it would be a multi unit and not a single family short term rental.
It is the norm in this region as every other VRBO in the area charges more per person once you get over a certain point. I’m still unsure what my base rate is per cabin but the extra won’t be ridiculous but it is the region standard here. It may be the norm in your market but there’s a large difference on the wear and tear of the house, holding tank usage, electricity and maintenance if there are 10 people or 18. There’s not much difference if I just increase the rate of if I increase the rate per person with a base rate. Once again, I do appreciate the input however.