Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Luca Shaw

Luca Shaw has started 3 posts and replied 5 times.

Hi all,

I am looking at a potential rental acquisition where the home contains a garage conversion into a room and it is unpermitted.


Note that seller has not included this room in the sq footage and i am not purchasing it with the assumption of conversion to permitted.


If i were to buy and turn into a rental - is there any liability to renting it out with that unpermitted conversion? I wouldn't advertise it as a bedroom and would make it clear that it is not to ever be a bedroom, but am concerned about the presence of an unpermitted room in general, but I may be overreacting. 

State: California

Thanks! 

Hello,

Have a 2/2 with no AC in southern California. Options are either to:

1. Install window AC/portable AC in the 2 rooms. Cost probably <=$~1k. cheap up front and low cost maintainence.
2. Have HVAC co install central AC or mini splits. Cost  ~$10-15k across the few bids I got it.

Is it worth it to get the central for future rent growth? Or just go cheap and do the portable/window? 

House is worth ~650k in an in demand area and rent will be slightly positive to P&I but negative to PITI and maintainence. I plan on potentially putting a 3rd bedroom on the house in 1-2 years.

Quote from @Greg M.:
Quote from @Joe Villeneuve:
Principle  reduction doesn't usually mean much until the end of a mortgage term.  If we're talking in the beginning, like here, it has very little impact on the $1000/month loss...maybe an average of $50/month over the course of 2 years.  Also, since it's invisible money, and useless unless you sell the property, it's just a rationalization on how much money is being lost here.  
More important, this $12k/year isn't just $12k/year.  There's an exponential effect that cash has that virtual money doesn't have because it is immediate.

Based on the numbers he gave and the expected $3000-$3500 rent covering P&I, it's likely that he has a ~600K mortgage. The principal reduction would average around $710 a month for the first two years.

Assuming a very low 2% YoY rent increase and the increasing principal reduction, he will "breakeven" after three years of renting.

I know you and I are on the opposite ends of how we view investments, but I do find it odd how you can say it is useless unless you sell the property. It's a store of wealth - just like owning a stock that doesn't pay a dividend or a couponless bond. It can be used as collateral, drawn from through a line of credit, or used in a 1031 once enough equity is built up. It also allows for postponement of taxes. 


 Thanks Greg. You are correct, 600k ish mortgage, so aboyt $710 equity build per month. This is also how I view keeping it and also as a retirement hedge - worst case if i can pay it off I can live there with no payment. 

Quote from @Allen Duan:

Echoing Charles here. Run your numbers as a MTR and see how that changes your analysis. We find that furnishing a 2 bedroom with pretty good quality is around $8-10k, a small investment in the big picture. Our properties are mostly in the South Bay, but we have 2 bedroom condos and duplex units renting out for $3500-4000 as MTRs. As a SFH, I imagine you can get more.


 Hey Allen, By MTR do you mean something like furnishedfinder? Are there others? 

Hi all,

Last year I bought a 2/2 SFH in a suburb of LA (ventura county) fully intending to use it as a primary home. 30 year fixed @ 5.375%. Recent developments in my career lead me to have to move about 2 hours away. That leaves me with deciding what I'm supposed to do with this property. Its a 50s property but I've updated a ton of things about it. Roof probably has a few years left on it, only real weakness is eventually I'll have some major mainline work needed.

My options appear to be the following:

1. Rent it out. I can get $3000-3500 rent pretty confidently after looking at comps and discussing with various property managers. This would leave me basically cashflow neutral/slightly positive on my P&I but negative after taxes, insurance, and expected maintenance (assuming 1.5% of home value in maintenance per year). After all of that, I'll be ~$1k negative per month but likely hoping for some solid appreciation as a source of return. I can afford negative -1k monthly with this new job but obviously I don't love it.

2. Sell it. I can probably sell it and after fees probably lose 20k or so (as far as down pmt + closing costs + improvements).


Renting (even though negative) seems like a good way to go because I have a good risk tolerance, however I am worried about California landlord laws + unexpected maintenance/capex. Looking for BP community suggestions as this is weighing on me.