Personally, I would get a HELOC and look for a duplex to buy. I feel like as prices go up, a lot of first time homebuyers will be priced out of single family homes (many already are) and they need to look at alternatives like townhomes so your home should appreciate well. Also, a 2 bed 1.5 bath townhome should be fairly easy to rent. Duplexes are very competitive right now, especially ones that will allow you to owner occupy - If both units are occupied, the seller first would need to be willing to give a tenant a 90 day notice first which many are not willing to do so. I know you said that you can take your time finding a duplex after you sell your townhome, but how long are you willing to wait? Selling seems a bit risky to me...Anyway, those are my personal thoughts, I'd be happy to answer any questions. About the fireplace...if it's broken, maybe just board it up and don't allow the tenants to use it. I think that's safer anyway as a rental. Also a note about the market, yes the market is crazy right now but Salem is still quite affordable compared to Portland and many other areas in the country!