I searched high and low on how procuring cause applies here. Seems most dispute are agent-to-agent about who deserve the commission. I have not yet seen one against the fsbo owner or other investors whose properties are not on the market.
If the property is currently listed I would of course reach out to the former agent as a courtesy. However, my LLC is buying the property and flipping it. It's offered as FSBO and not a MLS listing. I am offering no commission to anyone even myself. Also the fact the agent had abandoned and estranged the client and not continued the relationship is hard to deny. If I was an average investor I might not even give a darn, but since I am also a licensed agent I had an ethical duty to give fair warning to the buyers of their potential liability. Since it's not listed the buyers would be responsible if any commission claim arises.
The former agent didn't even know the buyers were thinking of buying this house again until the buyers called to ask for copies of the rejected offer since the buyers didn't keep a copy.
The agent even told the buyers that he's entitled to his share of the commission at the old offer price and the split per the old listing agreement, even if the house is now sold for less than that.
Good night and good luck!
This is why the public thinks we real estate agents are worse than used car salesman. At least the car salesman hustles hard to make a deal happen. This guy hasn't lifted a finger in 6 months and he wants the jackpot. Come to think of it, I don't even think he is a member of our MLS anyway; I don't see how he can even qualify for a commission.
I don't HAVE TO sell to these folks since I can always ramp up my own marketing and get new buyers. I'm going to wait a bit and see how interested these folks really are and what their lawyer says. I'm not trying to cut out the agent if he has a legitimate claim, but without ANY contract or agreement it really would be hard for him to claim anything. And if there was a buyer agency contract in place, the buyers can always choose to wait it out or fire the agent since he did not do his job and close the deal while he had all this time.
How happy are the buyers going to be to see this agent is keeping them from buying their dream home?