Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Leslie Carter

Leslie Carter has started 2 posts and replied 12 times.

Hi Andrea, I’m in the same situation as you and I am enraged at this point. My house is Upstate NY and I had a tenant on a 30 day eviction notice. She was supposed to leave by Mar. 30. Then the shutdown happened on the 15th and she’s used it as an excuse not to pay rent for a year. She has Section 8 assistance so I at least got $300 a month but she’s now almost $6000 in arrears.

On top of that the Section 8 folks sited my house for lead paint. (I just bought it 3 years ago and was never told there was a problem before). With the lead paint infraction this brought the Health Inspector. Yet another person to find anything they can so Section 8 doesn’t have to pay. I replace ALL of the windows in the house so i wouldn’t have any further delays, to the tune of $12,000 and I had to reside the top of the house for $3800. 

Let me say my house used to be beautiful. I renovated it so it was a place I was proud to rent. In addition to nonpayment this tenant is systematically ruining my home. She’s filthy and I don’t think she’s cleaned in a year. I’m talking garbage on the stairs and in common areas. Junk, furniture and garbage strewn all over the backyard. Like where were these people raised? The topper? She had a dog ( not allowed in the lease) and had him locked in the basement without being taken out. Yes poop and pee all over the basement. We’re talking weeks worth. My PM has to keep going over there to clean it up because its a health hazard and I have had to pay for a plumber to go there twice to snake out the sewer main. She’s flushing mask PPE and booties down the toilet!!!! How much can I take?

I have a lawyer and we’ve been trying to get her out since the memorandum. He got a judgement that she pay Nov, Dec, and Jan rent on time or she can be evicted within 24 hrs. She was supposed to be out on Feb 1. Then the moratorium was extended and even though I got a judgement during the initial moratorium the extension stayed her current eviction. Now since Feb 1 she’s taking advantage again and hasn’t paid a penny of rent. In addition she found the time to go down to the court and file a Covid Hardship case. The only one with hardship is me. She works 2 jobs and hasn’t paid rent in a year.

There is so much more like her heat being shut off and me having to turn it on so the pipes don’t freeze, the gas company calling me to tell me she’s under investigation for theft of services because she used  someone else’s SSN to open her account. Her running the washing machine and continuously flooding the basement because the hose wasn’t in the slop sink. Oh and my favorite. Once the water has built up enough it extinguishes the pilot light on the furnace. 

Do I sound frustrated??? OMG. Per my lawyer there isn’t much I can do. What I want to know is, is there some type of financial relief for landlords that don’t have a mortgage, but are in dire straits because they’ve had to put out so much money for repairs and maintenance. 

Hi all. Thanks for all of your input. I am still deciding if I’m going to go to court. I was told that in Erie County, I can garnish her paycheck or even her bank account.  I have a court date if Feb 26. Can anyone refer me to a lawyer in Buffalo that does Small claims for out of town landlords. I know it’s a long haul to actually get my money but it’s the principle of it. I appreciate it. 

@Ray Harrell I never equated the fact that they negotiated a move out agreement with not being able to go after the money. My PM lead me to believe that all I had to do was sue her in small claims. This is my first go at rental property and I’ve learned quite a lot in the 1 st year. Like how I should just let the $4500 go unfortunately 😩

Thank you Mitch. I’m beginning to agree with your thoughts. After more research I know now that the only thing I’ll leave with is a paper saying she owes me. Collecting is another chapter. Maybe I can write it off as a loss on my taxes?

Hello all. I wondered the same thing about the court proceedings. I am really upset that I was left out to dry. The amount got to be so much because My PM was trying to work out a payment plan but my PM wasn’t communicating with myself or the tenant. she filed to evict but her lawyer cancelled and that pushed us in to yet another month. It’s a big mess. I have to now fly to Buffalo for this and spend more money. 

And yes I need a new PM

I own a rental property in Buffalo NY and I’m an out of town landlord. I have an ex tenant that owes me $4500 in back rent. My property manager did file papers for eviction but when her lawyer went to court they made an agreement for her to move out instead without the full eviction. She left and now I’m still owed $4500. I flew to Buffalo and filed for a small claims court hearing and was granted one for later this month. Is this something I should fly in  and do myself or should I have a lawyer handle it? If I handle it I want to make sure I’m prepared. What do I need to bring. I know she doesn’t have the $ so I’m probably looking at garnishing her paycheck. 

Wow Nathan. This is really helpful. I was aware of some of your points , but things like referrals were always a gray area for me. I just wasn’t sure if asking for them was out of the scope of the norm. Now I know if I ask and get push back that this is not the company for me. I’ve also been talking to a company that charges a $50 per unit flat rate and $50 an hour for anything they do from making a phone call to sending an email. It’s hard to gauge what this will end up on average costing per month. 

I do have one further question I’d like to ask. Is it usual for a management Co to require that I have  a  specific amount of insurance coverage on my house. One comanpy is asking 2 million in liability and $1 million aggregated. 

thank you Christopher. I’ll check them out and let them know you referred me 

Wow. Great Matthew. It’s hard to choose a company without a personal reference. I’ll look them up and give them a call. Thank you so much 

Thank you Denice. I did look them up in a google search before posting and found mixed reviews which is why I was looking here to find someone with personal experience with them.I am contemplating going in to contract with them and will follow up here with my experiences. I was trying to get info from the local investors here on this forum.