Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Lenny Smith

Lenny Smith has started 1 posts and replied 14 times.

Originally posted by @Charles LeMaire:

Put the TAX QUESTION to rest! Assuming it is an inherited non-spousal traditional IRA, a non-minor must distribute the contents with in 10 years. It is taxable at your earned income rates. There is an exception for spouses, minors, person less that 10 years younger than the originator, and for disabled persons. Roths are distributed tax free. The basis reset does not apply.
https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/investing/inherited-ira-options/

If you have heard of Dave Ramsey, even listened to him, where did you come up with "Day Trader".  For persons that are unskilled with money, follow Dave Ramsey's rules!  Another good info source if you have some money skills is The Money Guys; they follow the FOO (Financial Order of Operations).
https://www.moneyguy.com/

The big difference I find is emotion based vs math based, for example, some folks should not have a credit card, some folks know to pay it off each month...

None of us out here in BP land have a clue about your situation, except you seem to thing Day Trading is a reasonable path.  

Use the Ramsey site to find an "advisor with the heart of a teacher" or maybe hit up the Money Guys.  Your concern about education help is real.  Let the advisor coach you on the numbers.  I am not hearing that you are currently up to the task by yourself.

C.

I honestly saw a couple things about day trading on the internet after making simple searches involving making investments.  I knew nothing about stocks or trading anything prior my searches.  I wish I knew what everyone has told me about trading prior to asking for advice because it has left me with very little advice regarding my actual situation and tons of opinions about me being ignorant for ever considering day trading.  I get it. It is not a reasonable thing to even consider, sometimes people are unaware of things. Now I am aware and we can move on, but seeing as this is the internet and first impressions are so strong my best bet at getting any further advice would probably be to go back to the drawing board, incorporate what I've learned and rephrase my questions.  I will check out Ramsey's site. thanks 

Originally posted by @Mary White:

There's nothing wrong with starting in real estate to see how you like it. I'd look for a 2-4 unit place and use your W-2 income to leverage and only use a small portion of your inheritance. You can hire a manager or do it yourself to figure it out. I'm a big believer of "you'll never know until you try." I'd also put a bit in the stock market (Roth IRA) and just let it marinate. Can you roll over the inheritance into your own IRA a bit at a time to save on taxes? Talk to an accountant ASAP and ask for help. It shouldn't cost very much and you can learn from somebody who isn't in a position to gain from your inheritance. There's also nothing wrong with walking away from a job and using a bit of the money to help invest in yourself and figure out your life. Just be intentional about your actions and please don't blow it on a new vehicle.

Thanks Mary!  That's the first thing my mother told me to do, buy a new vehicle. That's why she has been in debt most of her life though. I am not spending a dime of it on anything other than making more money. I don't understand enough to know what you mean by use my w-2 to leverage.  But it sounds like a decent idea. Thing is I don't know how easy it will be to find a decent place near me, pretty small area but maybe. 

I do have a brokerage account that I opened just to access TD ameritrades courses and paper money program but it is not an IRA.

The guy managing the transfer of the funds, seems like a really decent person and he has said he is making nothing off of it. He has given me some good advice and I think he would do so in the future, I plan on asking him some questions. 

And I agree and I'm glad you see it that way, I know a lot of people are saying dont quit the job, do as much as you can, fill the clock, cant afford to lose any $. I get it. But, it's also important to have the well being and state of mind conducive to making logical and grounded decisions about the future.  Easy to take it for granted when you have it. 

Originally posted by @Kitt Pyle:

Now you are sounding like you are beginning to listen to the advice that people are giving you.  

Generally, I would say find something part-time or keep your full-time job for now.  When you are not working, develop a hobby or business you can do on the side that you enjoy.  There is a need everywhere for handymen, gardeners, etc.  Get that business up and running so that it covers your expenses plus some for the unexpected.  Once you are consistently making that from your new endeavors, then quit your present job.   

In today's economy with so many people that have lost their jobs is not the time to voluntarily walk away from a job. In the meanwhile read the book I suggested earlier.  I read the book and have given one to each of my teenage grandchildren.   Once you have read the book you will have a much better idea of what to do with your inheritance.  A financially sound person has 5-7 different streams of income.  

Before day trading and hoping you will be one of the few great successes, make sure you are secure and sound financially.  Also, make sure you isolate your vulnerable day trading money from the rest of your resources. In other words, make sure each income stream can only use the money set aside for that business and not touch your other resources.  People today are sue-happy.  You do not want to have all your resources vulnerable to some unfortunate unexpected incident. 

 Maybe I will consider just asking for less hours.. Even though I have enough in savings to cover expenses for a while, I don't want to give up a steady income. Less stress, still more time to focus on other ways to make $. 

Originally posted by @Michael P.:

Just read Dave Ramsey’s “the total money makeover” and follow the plan in the book. Do not try to be a day trader or a real estate investor or you will part with your inheritance very quickly.

 Man, I will look into that book!  I have a ton of other books I am trying to get through but I love listening to his radio program when I catch it in the car. 

Originally posted by @Alexander Bacon:

@Lenny Smith The idea that you are trying to achieve financial independence is a costly idea in terms of time and effort which many people seem to overlook. To be blunt, if you can not figure out how to manage your time to begin this process, you will not make it. I work 84 hours a week at the moment, have a wife and two kids, and am beginning to invest in real estate on the side. I learned everything about the stock market on my own and am doing my best on the real estate side right now (with help from others on this site). My circumstances are not normal and I fully understand that but not having enough time is a complete cop out. If you watch tv, netflix, play video etc, you have time. If you spend time on social media, you have time. If you sleep more than 6 hours, you have time. It is all about time management and if you don't have the courage, willpower, and time management skills to simply begin at this point in your life, you will not magically have the grit to succeed just because you quit your job. You can do this so do not doubt yourself. But you need to push yourself right now given the current circumstances to mold yourself into someone who is a time management expert and someone who will stop at nothing. Quitting your job and using the "not enough time" excuse is a simple cop out that everyone uses on a daily basis but I guarantee it is not a question about time but it is a question about priorities. 

Well. I must say, this frustrated me. I have been trying to live my life for the past two years in a way that I can look back and say I couldn't have done anything more than what I did.  I'm sure there is something I could have done in hindsight, but not that I saw or could see at the time.  With that said, I have seriously tried to not waste a minute. For example, for this year, I was working nights everyday with two days off per week. I would wake up each morning at 6 am, I get to bed at 11-12 so that is 7-8 hours of sleep. I would study until I had to go to work, and then I would work until a little after 10.  On my two days off, I would wake up maybe a bit later to catch up on sleep so about 8 or 9 at the latest. I was ALWAYS tired. No matter what.  I felt completely burnt out 24/7. You say 6 hours of sleep? There is just absolutely no way. Maybe it works for you, but I can't do that.  And it isn't that I don't want to do that, or couldn't physically do it, I could force myself but if I am already barely absorbing what I am studying because I am always exhausted then getting less sleep would just make it worse. Anyways, on my two days off, I had them set up to land on days where I usually had a quiz/exam the day I went back to work so I could study on/off for two days.  In between studying for tests I would do other school work, take care of things around the house and other things that need to be done, and if I had time and the mental energy I would read a book or watch tv. 

I don't have social media whatsoever. I will admit though, I have often thought that I might have an issue with overthinking things that don't matter which results in me being so tired. Problem is I don't know how to fix this.  I can manage it quite well when I am in control of my life and my environment. But when I was working I would often bring stuff home with me that I really didn't need to. I admit that I have a lot of trouble separating myself from things sometimes and this definitely effects my focus and efficiency.

But I really feel like I have been using all of my time as best as I could. I used to have some problems years back and being lazy and sitting around consuming stupid stuff makes me feel like crap. The only time my tv has been on since I have been laid off is at night for noise while I sleep. I've been doing nothing but waking up, checking off lists, and trying to get as much as I can packed into this time that I have before I have to work again. This is another reason that I feel in my gut(which could be wrong, yes) that having more time could help me figure things out, I've never valued every minute of the day as much as I do now.  It might not sound that way to you, but hey, that's alright.  Until being laid off, I didn't have any priorities besides school and work. Whether it was a cop out or I really didn't have time, I never could just sit at my computer researching different paths to take or getting on sites like these and asking people wiser than me for advice. Anyways, I still appreciate your reply. It was motivating, and I don't totally disagree, I know I can always do and be better.  Thank you. 

Originally posted by @Alexander Bacon:

@Lenny Smith I would advise against stocks as many others have already said. I have been successfully trading stocks for a few years now but on the side. I have made about $10k in the last two months and have probably averaged about $2k a month for the last 4-5 years. I use $30k in my account and rinse and repeat. With that being said, I highly discourage this and I am personally trying to stop day/swing trading and get into real estate. Day/swing trading can be done and can be possible but you will soon learn that it is more time consuming than you think, analysis does not really mean as much as people think, and it is stressful. If you are determined to do this, then do it but I would be comfortable with losing $5-10k off the bat and hopefully you learn from the early mistakes quickly. I also highly highly recommend you use the thinkorswim paper trading platform for a minimum of three months. It has its flaws but if you can trade successfully with paper money of the same amount you would use with real money, for a minimum of one month, then you could try real money. If you have questions about analysis or anything at all about stocks, feel free to message me. Just be aware that if playing the stock market was so easy, everyone would do it. Also, carefully listen to all the "wealth gurus" on youtube. What you'll notice, besides the useless private groups and subscriptions they offer for a price, is that all day traders have real estate investments. ALL OF THEM. I would argue that 99% of the stock guys have built their wealth through real estate, not the stock market. Then look at all the real estate people on youtube. Very few talk about the stock market except to make comparisons to the returns you get through real estate. I HIGHLY recommend you stay on this website and learn everything you can about real estate and put your money there, not the stock market. This is just my two cents as someone who has played the stock market game with reasonable but not overabundant success. Again, feel free to message me with any questions and I can gladly answer them. I am 27 myself so we are at about the same age and can probably relate on a few levels.  

 Thanks for the reply.  I have been using paper money and what you said is what I planned on doing for the most part, using paper money to make successful trades and then trying out the real deal. 

Here's the thing about quitting my job though, if I don't... there is absolutely no chance that I am going to learn anything about anything.  Working 40 hours+ a week and going to school full time leaves no brain power and no time to learn about real estate. Sure I could maybe make time one day a week but I really would like to make something happen within a few years, not a decade. 

I appreciate the offer to help, and I will probably end up sending you a message one of these days.  Thanks man. 

Originally posted by @Kitt Pyle:

People have already said it, but I will say it more plainly.  Day trading is playing Russian Roulette.  It is basically gambling on trends.  The fallout from this COVID-19 will get a lot worst before it gets better.  

You said that presently you are unemployed.  Use this time to learn about how money really works.  I recommend reading How Money Works, Stop Being A Sucker.  Yes, you have been blessed.  I recommend investing in cash flowing real estate. Once you have made lots, and I mean lots of money with a constant stream of excess money coming in, then do you da trading gig.  

With all the answers you have provided thus far, it sounds like you have made up your mind to gamble your money in hopes of making lots of money in a very short time.  This is like becoming the number one athlete in the world.  It is one in a million.  But then you don't see all the hard losses, etc. Two birds in the hand are better than one in the bush. 

If you decide to gamble your money in day trading, I wish you lots of luck. 

Thanks for the reply. 

I haven't made up my mind at all, that's why I am asking for advice.  Based on the advice so far it, trading doesn't sound so good anymore.  I'm not unemployed, if I was I probably wouldn't be asking the questions that I have.  I was laid off, but I have been asked to come back and will be going back in a couple days.  I might decide to quit, I might not.  Going to continue to consider different opinions and think it over long and hard before I make any decisions. I will look into that title as well as 'cash flowing real estate', (I have no idea what that it is).  Thanks!

Originally posted by @Charles LeMaire:

@Lenny Smith - I noticed that you joined BP today.  Welcome.  I'm curious why you're asking about this on two fronts.  First, you realize this is an RE site, not a Wall St. investing site, right?  You've confused podiatrist with dentist.   Second, it seems by your comments that you're relatively sure it can be done and that you can do it.  GO FOR IT!!!  Unless you are Peter Lynch reincarnated, someone out there can use that $150K+ you inherited.  I recall a fellow telling me that most people win in a casino; as I recall he had to borrow rent money after that experiment.  

I don't believe you mentioned what you do.  No idea how bad it could be; change!  You said you're off at present.  I hope you've taken some time to attempt to learn about some jobs you might like.  Or perhaps taken time to watch Mike Rowe's Dirty Jobs.  Seriously, there are a lot of great RE pod-casts. 

Clearly, this is a RE site and yes, I play in RE.  RE can be very lucrative, but there are often bumps in the road. Some avenues of RE requires a fair amount of capital, some don't. But the folks that WIN have very positive attitudes and a lot of drive.  

Given you are asking on the Wall St side of the fence, I would find an advisor that you can trust. I assume you are referring to an non-spousal inherited IRA (they now have a 10 year RMD clock). I would pull most/all of it now while the market is down, pay the tax, and get it reinvested to allow it to ride the market back up. Pay the tax now when it is smaller and taxes are lower (Trump's taxes are lowest in my lifetime!). Once you have allowed it to climb, you have studied and learned about something (Wall St or RE or something) then work you way into that when you have a clue.

Get a job you can stand and keep it while you figure out what you want to do.  If you can work close to your target area, do it.  Figure out how to FLY before you step off the cliff.

Regards from a Grumpy Old Man,

Charles LeMaire

Thanks for the reply! Great advice..  

I honestly just googled 'financial advice' and this forum popped up so I used it, along with a few others.  Was just trying to ask as many 'educated' people for advice in the shortest amount of time. Didn't realize this was a real estate site until after I posted. 

As far as being sure that I can day trade successfully, I'm only as sure as blind ambition has made me, I 100% acknowledge that I don't know the half about it and am only going by the few accounts of people who claim to have made it work. 

I don't like getting into what I do, I don't really think it is relevant anyways.  I have used my time off to look into other avenues, but I have already been asked to go back to work so I'm still in the bind of deciding if I should quit before I have found something else or not.  I am pretty hung up, I must admit, on figuring out something I can do to make a somewhat consistent income on my own time or from home.  There are not many jobs in my area to begin with and right now especially with everything that is going on. I live in a very small town in a very remote area of my state.  And, honestly, I'm sick and tired of being miserable and depressed--the job that I do I come into contact with and talk with people from all over the area and most of them are miserable and depressed too at the handful of other jobs available.  And of course, the hallmark response to this is "that's life", "it's like that everywhere".  Well, I'm tired of it.  If I go on much longer at this job I won't have a mind to work with, I won't have ambition or drive to accomplish anything. 

As far as the inheritance, I am expecting to take the money out of the account soon, and pay the taxes.  The guy managing the account has told me essentially the same thing about it being cheaper to do it right now.  The only downside to that is as soon as I have that in my name I will no longer be able to get financial aid for school.  Might effect me other ways too I'm not sure.  But I definitely plan on reinvesting some of it.

 anyways, thanks for the advice.  

Originally posted by @Account Closed:

This isnt going to end well.....................................Ninja Trading.  These companies make their money by choosing the right name.  I bet they spend millions focus grouping .

Tasty Trade.....yum yum yum.

Of the Planets 8,000,000,000 inhabitants how many have made it trading the day?

You are being sort of obnoxious. If I'm wrong, uneducated, ignorant about any of this stuff I have no problem admitting it and listening to someone wiser than me.  But I don't think you have any intentions of offering any helpful advice, and if that's the case I don't see why you are wasting your time responding to my post. 

Originally posted by @Aaron K.:

@Lenny Smith you can only make 3 day trades a week before being flagged as a pattern day trader which puts the $25k restriction in place, the account probably lets you open it with as little as $400 but they are expecting you to do buy and hold investing.  

When I say you are behind the algorithms, you the day trader are trying to do the same thing the computer is, but you will likely have delayed information, slower reaction times, and the computer will make math based decisions 100% of the time, not to mention the computers that do this are right next to the NYSE and have maxed out their internet connections so that they can beat out other trading computers.

The program I am referring to is called NinjaTrader I think, from the little I read about it, it sounded like they only required $400 for a futures trading account and there was some way around the pattern day trading rule.  I don't remember what that was, it might have been trading in a specific future.  But you could still be right, I wouldn't put it past them to make it sound appealing to someone like me just so I would open an account. 

And I think I understand what you are saying, I would be trading against a lot of computers that would have the advantage. Yeah.  Makes sense...    Well... I think I am still going to continue with the courses on TD, I don't think it could hurt to learn about this stuff. The guy who managed my inheritance before it was set to be given to me said he would help me put 10k or whatever I wanted into an investment account of my own, so I could apply whatever I learn to that down the road.