Hi @Lauren Pitts. I've trialed a bunch of the solutions out there and just recently dumped iGMS for YourPorter after looking into BookingAutomation.com, Tokeet, Lodgify, Elina, Rentlio, Beds24, SuperHostTools, Hostfully, Nueva, and Uplisting.
One the things you'll find in working with anything that costs less than a $100/mo is that the design of most STR apps/services is worse than the platforms' apps/sites themselves. In my testing I actually found BookingAutomation and Beds24 (same product, different pricing scheme) to be the most feature and channel complete, but it was like trimming a bonsai tree with a machete: way too many buttons when all I needed was automated messaging, calendar sync, and a universal inbox.
Additionally I liked YourPorter because it hit the 3 channels I need: Air, VRBO, Booking, had a mobile-first UI, and duped the messaging automation I had with iGMS, without charging me for every other channel I added on.
What I was pleasantly surprised about was that there was a nice amount of logic built in for "if-then" automation that can increase listing revenue if enabled. As an example, if there is no one checking into a rental before or after a guest, Porter sends a one-off message asking if they want to stay another night for a discounted rate. If it's not a back-back turnover, that's just a dead day for me so offering it as an add-on day's a win-win for both guests and me.
Additionally, the private label website generation is dead simple and allowed me a better way to have past guests book direct, save the 10-20% on the platform fees, and avoid scrolling past dozens of competing spaces on the way to re-booking mine.
Again, this is all highly specific to my own needs and interests. By all means outline your top 10 "must have" features, then go out and try out the different solutions to find out what works best for you.
Hope this helps! Hey Cliff.. perfect! Thanks. I had Your Porter before Smartbnb. It is good to hear that they have kept evolving and are even better than before and that you are pleased. I sacrificed some functionality options (mobile ap) for a more visually appealing Smartbnb user-interface and other functionality (AI question detection). You are absolutely right that those 3 functions are the main needs. I would also add the AI question detection feature that sends canned answers automatically saves me tremendous time (when it works). Also I really want to have unique pin codes automatically generated and sent to guests. I'm piloting Smoobu now. They have very reasonable prices (comparable to Your Porter) and automate unique pin codes with my Igloohome smart locks with reservations from a variety of platforms. They also sync pricing. I don't know yet if they are buggy or not. Will keep you posted and if not,Your Porter will get a second look! Thanks!!