I made the decision to sell my rental property in OR that I've had for 18 years - the time was right for reasons I won't get into. Now I'm trying to figure out where to invest the proceeds - I estimate it will be about $400k - and defer taxes. My priority is income more than capital gains. I don't have high income that I need to shelter (semi-retired). I live in California and would invest out of state. I am overwhelmed trying to figure out where and how to reinvest, and the clock on a 1031 exchange will tick once I get an offer and close. We put in the listing that I want to close after 1/1 so I estimate I have until mid-Feb to identify a replacement property. I plan on being invested in real estate for another 20 years. I have one other property in Bellingham WA near the university with a great property manager but the prices there are too high to get a decent cash on cash return right now.
Here is what I've considered so far and I'm open to other ideas. One of the mistakes I made in OR is not taking enough time to search for the right property (and not switching property manager years ago). Any thoughts on how to make a decision and move forward within my time frame?
1) Buying another property - I would have to figure out what markets to potentially look for a replacement property. I'm okay with managing a property manager. I'm concerned I won't be able to identify a replacement property in time as so far I haven't even identified which markets to look in. I do like neighborhoods near colleges where one year leases are the norm. Any suggestions for me to research?
2) 721 exchange into an UPREIT. I like the diversity of eventually being in a REIT, but I can't go back and do anymore 1031 exchanges if I am unhappy with the UPREIT I choose. It also is very hard for me to really understand the cash flow and fees of an UPREIT to evaluate if the investment is right for me.
3) DST - I'm not crazy about investing in a DST because I'd have to do another 1031 exchange when the property sells and pay another load to buy into another DST and if the DST has only 1 property it wouldn't provide the diversification benefit of an UPREIT. I would consider a DST as a backup option in case I can't identify a replacement property in time, though I have the same problem as an UPREIT which is really understanding the cash flow and fees.
TIA,
Laura