Hey Colette -
I'm a little late to the party, but also thought I'd post my thoughts since I own a similar property in the neighborhood.
First, to the area, its lower-end, working class (C-D Properties). There's long term potential for appreciation, but it will take a while. I am pro-78207, but be patient...like 5-10 years patient.
On the underwriting, purchase price seems typical for the area, but everything else seems off. The initial repair costs is probably low depending on the condition, is it occupied? Foundation problems are common for the area. I ended up just shimming the foundation for my big house and it was still $3,000. If I had sprung for full foundation it would have been $10,000 alone. Closing costs and points are low on the schedule. Rents...you might be able to get this, but it depends on the layout. Insurance was actually high, but it might be a flood plain.
Utilities! Once you get a solid handle on the initial repairs and the rents check out, this would be the main question mark. Is it split or common? A lot of houses in San Antonio are old houses that were split into several "units".I have some houses that are common water, common gas, but never common electricity. On the gas and water, sometimes I do the RUBS, and sometimes I just eat the cost. I would be hard pressed to buy a house with shared electricity. First, there's the expense risk of how much your tenants are going to spend, but the real issue would be financing. Banks (or at least the ones I've used) want to know if they are putting a lien on a SFH or a MFH. What saved me in my case, was that the property had two meters since the 1930's so the City of San Antonio gave me a letter of nonconforming use, saying it was ok that my property was a duplex. I had another friend who attempted the same thing (in a house that looks very similar to yours) and was unable to get a letter, which was fine because he was in the due diligence phase, but it's something to watch out for.
Anyways, hope that helps. Feel free to shoot me any deals you might be looking at. MFH is tough in SA right now!
Kyle