Originally posted by @Brian Mathews:
I just don't have the patience to have people stomping all over my house, using my kitchen, etc... My home is my castle and this is where I come to get away from it. And not by locking myself in my room either. If I want to walk around MY house in my underwear then that's what I want to do. Good money or not. Some things are more important than money. I might be a little older than you and have less patience. Who knows? But if somebody comes to visit or for too long my house it begins to irritate me. Where I'm at now, I wouldn't let my brothers or friends live with me anymore.
I figure... most people live with spouses/kids and deal with that for free. Why wouldn't I deal with other people for fairly good money for a while until I get better relatively passive income going?
My house literally makes more on it's own renting out rooms than most people do working full-time minimum wage jobs. I remind myself of that often, and suddenly minor roommate annoyances aren't so bad. Plus SFH tenants income.
You might be older. It does take patience and being a cheap person, but I also have a wing of the house that's larger than my previous apartments to myself.
I've lived in apartments where the entire apartment was smaller than my bedroom. My bedroom is private, then I've got shared living spaces. I've got more personal space than I did in an apartment I had. And I get money to share my common areas, instead of me paying to share apartment common areas.
It is sacrificing being naked on the couch. We also watch "TV" on our own iPads in common areas, so there's no fighting over a TV or hearing their crap shows.
I don't feel locked in my room. I can walk around in anything I could on the beach. I learned to be very clear with potential roommates upfront about what kind of house this is and what to expect. If you don't, yeah. roommates will take a mile if you give an inch, and cause problems. It's a retreat for all of us... very quiet compared to most roommate situations. You definitely have to find people who like a quiet house... otherwise you're dealing with stereos, TVs, and noise. I also wouldn't live with 18 year old party types who want to throw a party every day.
But, yeah, people do use the kitchen and that gets old. And other people aren't as clean as I am and don't help out much. Most of the people I've had either are so busy or travel a lot that I rarely see them, or are the types that just prefer to hang out in their rooms. I choose people who like their/my house as a quiet, private retreat.... definitely important to find people who like a quiet house instead of a social/party house. Having roommates plus their friends/dates over all the time would suck. Mine are quiet at home and don't have people over much.
It would be nice to be able to run naked around or blare my TV at 3 a.m. if I feel like it if I lived alone again. I can see that. I'll eventually live alone, run naked, and not be bothered by any tenant ever. I wouldn't necessarily do this for 20 years. At some point it would get old.
I wouldn't let anyone other than my potential kids/parents/spouse live with me free. I don't enjoy living with people necessarily, but I like the extra money.
All sorts of tenants annoy me, whether roommates or SFH tenants. Roommates here give me more rental income than one SFH I had, so I can stand living in an "bedroom apartment/house wing" and sharing a kitchen/livings/etc. I don't really cook, so sharing a kitchen doesn't drive me insane. There are multiple living rooms, so that also helps. Come to think of it, I don't want to own SFH with tenants forever either-- not unless I hire a property manager and they're a huge cash cow.
I wouldn't want to do this roommate situation if it was a tiny house, or if my bedroom was near the other bedrooms. I can still hear a little noise at times, but no worse than a normal apartment. It's like having our own apartments (bedrooms) within a house and sharing the common areas.
Utilities and repairs can eat up a lot of the profits if you're not careful, and there's wear/tear on one's house. My profit ratio has definitely improved since I first started this. I'm also careful not to get "work at home" people, or retired people, or people without a job/college who are home 24/7. Those types would drive most anyone nuts.... and run up the utility bill.
Someone with a brand new house and no experience doing this (and understand of the insurance/utility cost implications) I would suggest they not rent out their rooms. Same with people who don't know what roommate rules are necessary and how to enforce those rules. Some people don't realize that normal insurance won't necessary cover all the risks associated with rooming houses. I talked to my insurance guy extensively and planned for the worst. I also don't allow pets (usually; a few exceptions over the years), smoking, swimming pools/hot tubs, firepits, etc... my insurance wouldn't tolerate that in a shared living situation. I also wouldn't do the 'rent a room' thing in some very tenant friendly states. My state tends to protect "rent a room in your house homeowners" from bad tenants. For most people, I wouldn't actually recommend renting out rooms unless they really know what they're getting themselves into in terms of: insurance, repairs, liability, noise, screening people, state tenant-landlord laws, etc.
The main irritating thing about roommates is when they whine about silly stuff- "my internet went down" 5 minutes after it went down. I learned quick that sharing internet with anyone is a terrible idea (and a liability). Sharing only common are furniture, and nothing else-- certainly never sharing food or condiments or paper towels-- is the way to go. The less you share, the better. And pick a cleaning schedule upfront. And include roommate house rules in the lease. The first batch of people complained about the cleaning schedule, so we modified it and now anyone who moves in knows how we clean upfront.
People don't clean nearly enough here, and that's very annoying for sure. But it's decent looking. For thousands a year, I don't mind cleaning my house an extra time or two a year when I really think about the money. It's annoying that some roommates I've had didn't always do their fair share of cleaning, but I'll deal with it when I run the financial numbers. It's also irritating that I do the yard work, repairs, pay utilities, and all that non-sense. Including utilities is a terrible, terrible idea. Since I allow short-term, it's just too tedious to calculate utility shares every month.
I would definitely suggest anyone doing this include monthly or bi-weekly maid service in the rent as a required fee. I really, really should have done that.
I don't plan to do this forever. At some point, I'll settle down... and have to deal with my spouse/kids who don't pay rent yet make noise and dirty my house. :D
Roommates and SFH tenants all annoy the crap out of me and can be whiny and entitled sometimes, but I keep reminding myself of the numbers. Early-ish retirement, fewer hours I have to work now, and starting to get some passive income going. Eventually I don't want to have to deal with roommates or single family home tenants--- either I want property managers and repairmen to deal with all of that non-sense, or I'll find a more passive income approach.
Living with roommates tells you a lot about yourself and other people. More than I would ever have wanted to know...