Thank you all for your feedback. @Drew Sygit @Nathan Gesner@Michael Magno @Jacob Bohrer
As I said, this property is in MI (Michigan) I don’t think it effects anything but we live in CA. They were on month to month agreements with the previous owner. We spoke to both of them and they’re going to stay. We’ll be signing 1yr lease agreements with the new rent effective 3/1/21. They’ve lived there 10 & 12 years and really like living there. One is awesome, the other wanted to complain about previous owner but understands that was him, not us. We increased a little more than 20% but it’s still slightly under market. Managing ourselves only because it’s only two units and PM in the area isn’t interested in something that small (at least not at a reasonable rate) Michael, curious, What’s a “comfortable” Cap rate and cash on cash in your eyes? We were blindsided by the property taxes on this property and disappointed in our realtor not knowing we’d have to pay a homestead tax since we didn’t live in MI (basically doubled the estimate - leading to the lower return rates) Lesson learned for sure. Thank you all again, guess we need to read more forums but we’ve learned a lot with our first and looking forward to the next one.