@Eliot M. Man, a lot has happened since I originally posted this. We did follow through with this purchase, and we also purchased three more parks. We currently have seven lot rents and about 100 POH. The park that I originally made this post about did very well last year. We had a lot of expenses right after the purchase because of deferred maintenance, but after that was taken care of, the expense ratio was not outrageous. We made about 95% cash-on-cash with that deal. We purchased another park in August of last year, and that one was in very bad condition. We are remodeling many of the homes still, and using the cashflow to do that work, so our expenses are high with that one. We have not made a profit on that park yet, and we have about 5-6 more months of rehab since we are using cashflow to do repairs. We just closed on another park last month, which was in much better condition and had 26 POH and 5 lot rents. I foresee our expense ratio being small with that park. Last month our expense ratio on all of our parks was 50%, including the remodeling expenses for the distressed park we bought. I had a meeting with our in-house manager yesterday and we are confident we can get that down to 35%.
I am convinced the POH vs. TOH debate is regional. In our area, lot rents are scarce. In fact, the last park we bought was owned by a family who has had the park for about 15 years. He told me he never raised the lot rents for the 5 TOH because, and I quote, "Lot rents are a thing of the past." So, they are paying $85 per month for their lot rents. The second park we bought had 2 TOH, one paying $75 and the other paying $100 for lot rent. We have found that to be about the average for the very few lots being rented in our city. The numbers don't seem like they would work for us to convert them unless we could get $300 or more for lot rents. Surrounding areas are getting $235, so I don't think it would work for us.
A previous comment said that financing would be based on lot rent + value of home, but we have not found that to be the case with the local banks that we have used. Their appraisals have used both income and market approach, and they are making the loans based on the rent being collected, just like an apartment building. I think this may be different in larger cities.