Originally posted by @Lynnette E.:
I have a replacement cost policy. You can reduce the premium by increasing the deductible. Depending on the amount of cash you are willing to put into fix the damage before the insurance kicks in it may be worth it to switch to a replacement policy with a higher deductible. Ask you agent to run the policy cost with various deductibles.
I have RCV too, but Lynette does a good job laying out the downside and upside. For instance, I had a break-in at a house recently when the tenant was on vacation and they busted up a door and window I had to have replaced. My receipts are about $750 for that. However, I have a $1000 deductible so insurance isn't giving me anything for the incident. That said, I probably pay $200-300/year less than if I had a $500 deductible. If I had a $500 deductible, then they would've given me back $250 (750 - 500), which is basically the difference between the premium on the 2 policies.
1) $1000 deductible: $700/year premium + $750 in damages = $1450
2) $500 deductible: $950 year/premium + $750 in damages - $250 from insurance = $1450
So basically it's all a wash, but I will usually save money with a higher deductible in the long run (as long as your tenants don't get broken in on!).